邹恒甫致钱颖一学弟的学生蔡洪滨的第二封公开信

一个理想主义者的感悟：
    大才之人，常特立独行，但因其泽被众民，故后世感恩而铭记之；小才之人，行与常人无二，因其山高水长之风德，亦为万世敬仰。才德之取舍，人性之权衡。世间之名利，先生阖苦求若此？
      吾，无才者也，常愿诸公释怀，促膝相向，为我辈开恬淡之灵魂沃土？如是，则青年幸哉！中国幸哉！何如？

我幻想有一天，各位老师坐在一起。如果成真，则中国之学术有未来；不然，则中国之学术无未来。

请看邹老师的信：这也可以说明为什么蔡洪滨出钱请方汉明，陈玉宇，周黎安，albert park， vernon henderson等人帮他写应用论文。
但是，蔡洪滨要赶上邹恒甫老师的引用率是不可能的。邹老师在无名气的期刊《review of development economics》里发的一文就有355个引用，比蔡洪滨在JPubE和AER两篇最多引用加起来还多。有时，高引用率并不一定要在好期刊，邹老师的论文说明了此点，了不起！

after-drunk 发表于 2012-3-22 18:35
请看邹老师的信：这也可以说明为什么蔡洪滨出钱请方汉明，陈玉宇，周黎安，albert park， vernon henderson ...

但是，蔡洪滨要赶上邹恒甫老师的引用率是不可能的。邹老师在无名气的期刊《review of development economics》里发的一文就有355个引用，比蔡洪滨在JPubE和AER两篇最多引用加起来还多。有时，高引用率并不一定要在好期刊，邹老师的论文说明了此点，了不起！
State corroding federalism[PDF] from kuleuven.ac.be
H Cai… - Journal of Public Economics, 2004 - Elsevier
Competition among local governments in a decentralized political system is often thought to
discipline lazy or corrupt officials, improving public good provision and increasing welfare.
Some scholars note possible distortions due to spillovers or a 'race-to-the-bottom', but ...
Cited by 170 - Related articles - All 18 versions
Does competition for capital discipline governments? Decentralization, globalization, and public policy[PDF] from ucla.edu
H Cai… - The American economic review, 2005 - JSTOR
Does competition to attract mobile capital discipline governments? Two bodies of literature
contend that it does. The first sees such discipline as harmful. Scholars argue that the fear of
capital outflows restricts governments from providing welfare services, environmental ...
Cited by 149 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 25 versions

中国学者最容易学邹恒甫写论文，发在初，中，高三级期刊，都得到较高引用率。一切都不神秘，一切都顺乎心意，一切都不故作姿态。（邹恒甫按：按国际语法标准，我们把所有顿号都变为逗号。）回复@寒江独钓江南春：引用率最重要！例如， Samuelson 最早在Economica 发了他最伟大的发现现实偏好理论； Buchanan在Economica发了他的俱乐部理论； Coase也是在Economica上发了他的公司的性质。
回复@寒江独钓江南春：郎咸平如果继续努力，我们都很难超过他。他多年不写论文，也一直在全世界的前3%啊。科斯有三篇文章都发在1.5流和二流水平期刊（Economica 和 Journal of Law and Economics）有四万多引用： The problem of social cost RH Coase - 1960 - Cited by 18723 - The nature of the firm RH Coase - Economica, 1937 - Cited by 21446 -
The composition of public expenditure and economic growth[PDF] from worldbank.org
…, V Swaroop, H Zou - Journal of monetary economics, 1996 - Elsevier
Noting that the literature has focused on the link between the level of public expenditure and
growth, we derive conditions under which a change in the composition of expenditure leads
to a higher steady-state growth rate of the economy. The conditions depend not just on the ...
Cited by 807 - Related articles - All 15 versions
Explaining international and intertemporal variations in income inequality[PDF] from cenet.org.cn
…, L Squire, H Zou - The Economic Journal, 1998 - Wiley Online Library
This paper explores the propositions that, income inequality is relatively stable within
countries; and that it varies significantly among countries. A new and expanded data set
provides broad support for both propositions. Drawing on a political economy and capital ...
Cited by 724 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 20 versions

Fiscal decentralization and economic growth: A cross-country study…, H Zou - Journal of Urban economics, 1998 - Elsevier
We use a panel data set of 46 countries over the 1970–1989 period to investigate the
relationship between fiscal decentralization and economic growth. We find a negative
relationship between fiscal decentralization and growth in developing countries, but none ...
Cited by 497 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 10 versions

Fiscal decentralization, public spending, and economic growth in China[PDF] from nccu.edu.tw
…, H Zou - Journal of Public Economics, 1998 - Elsevier
This study of China demonstrates how the allocation of fiscal resources between the central
and local governments has affected economic growth since reforms began in the late 1970s.
We find that a higher degree of fiscal decentralization of government spending is ...
Cited by 517 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 21 versions

如果各高校搞引用率（排除自己引用自己，如IDEAS/RePEc），那会把科研人员和教授们都逼疯的。

ehelloe 发表于 2012-3-22 23:49
有两个疑问：
（1）有人讲真正搞学术研究的人，其研究的水平与质量不应按引用率来衡量，那应该按什么来衡量 ...
IDEAS/repec有三十四指标：
http://ideas.repec.org/e/pzo17.html#lists
更多请看邹恒甫：
http://ideas.repec.org/e/pzo17.html

本文来自: 人大经济论坛 学术道德监督 版，详细出处参考： https://bbs.pinggu.org/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1396934&page=9&from^^uid=2773380

after-drunk 发表于 2012-3-22 22:51
如果各高校搞引用率（排除自己引用自己，如IDEAS/RePEc），那会把科研人员和教授们都逼疯的。

赞成

潜心学术

看看章毅师兄如是说:     蔡洪滨的角色--赢者的咒诅

恒甫兄,
     我在2003年1月初在你家见了蔡洪滨之后就想提醒你他的人品.但你的固执害了你.你太欣赏稍有一点才华的人.你这脾气不改,今后你还是认识不到真正的好人.
     我后来了解了蔡的一点情况:他的人品实在不怎么样!四年来,我提醒过你.你又是多么地固执己见和固执成见!最近,他在中国也入民主党了.
     你老兄被他和张维迎坑害到如此状况,我只能替你扼腕叹息.
     不过,他也是坐在万人咒骂的位子上.真是应验了他和张所学的对策论的老话:赢者的咒诅.
     望今后你少遇此等小人.
     看了你对张维迎的质问信.你写得非常好.武常崎是好人.徐信忠是一个不玩花招的人:张龙小兄弟早就说过.陆正飞我不认识.
     多保重.中国有良知的人都知道你是好样的.
     章毅于新加坡
    2007年8月1日