以下是引用dgxc在2007-5-4 16:25:00的发言: non sense ranking
Journal of economic literature and journal of economic perspective are survey journals. They are high quality and actually these are the only two journals I read every issue for fun. but ususally people don't count their papers in these journals as academic contribution.
AER is definitely more influenctial than econometrica. The editor of econometrica admitted this and this journal is transforming to face a broader audience. This is one important reason that they have Acemoglue as editor now.
"ususally people don't count their papers in these journals as academic contribution"???夸张了吧? 随便举个例子Krugman1987年发在 journal of economic perspective 上的Is free trade passe?不是学术文章吗?你知道这篇论文在国际经济学领域的引用率吗? 还有萨缪尔森04年发在这杂志上的论文"where Ricardo and Mill........."的影响力你知道吗?