楼主: 张建平
2628 3

[张建平] [原创]关于货币发行的“压岁钱理论” [推广有奖]

  • 0关注
  • 78粉丝

贵宾

大师

25%

还不是VIP/贵宾

-

威望
5
论坛币
49357 个
通用积分
10574.8512
学术水平
1474 点
热心指数
1318 点
信用等级
987 点
经验
129409 点
帖子
12241
精华
12
在线时间
2531 小时
注册时间
2008-9-25
最后登录
2023-10-8

+2 论坛币
k人 参与回答

经管之家送您一份

应届毕业生专属福利!

求职就业群
赵安豆老师微信:zhaoandou666

经管之家联合CDA

送您一个全额奖学金名额~ !

感谢您参与论坛问题回答

经管之家送您两个论坛币!

+2 论坛币

副题:谈一谈为何我支持“按人头发钱”

冬至已过春节将至。如果春节时你的父母给未成年的你、或者为人父母的你给你的孩子发压岁钱的时候说:“记得夏天时还我啊”,这是借贷还是“发压岁钱”呢?

但是经济学的货币理论却习惯把央行向商业银行的借贷叫做“货币发行”。不是吗?如果不是,那么货币是怎样“发行”的?如同父母给孩子压岁钱那样把货币的所有权赋予孩子而无须归还吗?如果是这样父母就不会说“记得归还”了,都是父母的孩子,手心手背都是肉,为何央行的压岁钱只发给商业银行这些孩子,却不见发给普通民众?

 

经济学的货币理论可以说是一塌糊涂。为数众多的货币拜物教者说钱是万能的,钱多能使鬼推磨,重赏之下有勇夫,拼命敛钱聚财;而那些为数不多但也不少的“明白人”说钱一不能吃二不能穿,越是关键时候越是废纸,所以货币当局才会拼命印钞票糊弄百姓。但不管怎么说,在货币为何物,货币量如何确定这些最基本的问题还没有个所以然的时候,基于货币发行的货币经济已经实实在在风风火火地发展着了。尽管经济学家尚且说不清楚钱为何物从何而来,但是民众起码可以要求“发钱”要公平公开吧?就像孩子通常不会问父母钱从何来有多少一样,但是多数都会计较兄弟姊妹所得的压岁钱是否一样多。

如果说要用一个词汇来代表当今人类的文明与进步的话,“公平”二字也许是最恰当的。所以,虽则理论上《西方经济学的终结》已经说明当前的货币经济制度无法持续稳定运行,但是从现实出发,我支持那些提倡“按人头发钱”的建议,就因为这样做法符合“公平”二字,因此而“文明”。

 

不过有必要说清楚一点,我这里支持的“发钱”是真正的发钱,是发压岁钱式的发钱,也就是从货币当局那里发来的钱,而不是从财政当局那里转移支付过来的钱。现在经济危机当前,不少地方政府从财政里拿出钱来发给当地民众,一些国家的财政当局也向货币当局举债给民众发钱,这种发钱办法我是不太乐意附和。

为何不认同从财政当局那里给公民发钱?因为这在道理上说不通。在经济学理论当中,财政当局和公民都属于“经济体内”,钱放在财政部和放在公民的口袋里,就如同放在一个人(经济体)的左口袋和右口袋,把这些钱倒来倒去没有意思,整个衣服口袋里的钱的总数目不会有任何增加。财政当局的钱来源于公民纳税,用公民的纳税钱给公民发钱还不如压根儿就别收税http://finance.sina.com.cn/g/20081223/03185670799.shtml,因此“取之于民用之于民”的税收游戏没有意思。税收政策的完整说法是“取之于部分公民用之于另一部分公民”,但是这就等同于让几个孩子当中的老大(财政当局)牵头把老二的钱分一份儿给小三。这不是发钱,谁见过哪一家的孩子之间在相互发压岁钱?

学过西方经济学的读者都知道,在部门分析法当中,三部门体系就包括政府(政府、厂商、居民)。如果有读者对财政当局是经济体内一员这种说法还有迷惑,只要想一想“政府投资”“政府采购”“国库”“国有资产”“国有(营)企业”“国家向国企要求分红”“国企间的相对借贷”等等这些事情也就清楚了。

那么,为何赞同由货币当局给公民发钱?这要先回答“父母在发压岁钱的时候会不会也给自己发一份”这个问题。答案是“不会!”。父母两个钻在被窝里互相发压岁钱相互过一过当孩子的瘾无妨,在被窝外边当中孩子面就免了吧,这样做没有意义,太滑稽。这说明在发压岁钱这件事情上面,“父母”和“孩子”不是一个群体。经济学货币理论流派不少也一致赞同“货币当局外生于经济体”这种逻辑。只有货币当局才是包括财政当局和厂商、居民在内的经济体这些“经济孩子”的共同的父母。既然家里的钱都是父母掌管,他真的把钱“发给”而不是“借给”孩子们,才能叫做“压岁钱”,孩子们才会手里有钱或者手里的钱才会真正地增加。货币当局是经济体的父母这种论断说明了由货币当局发压岁钱的责任和义务所在。

光有责任义务还要有能力,这对于掌控货币发行大权的货币当局来说更不是一个问题了。在这个经济体家庭里,孩子们一致拥戴的货币当局父母有责任让经济体孩子们手里的钱不断增多,让他们享受节日的乐趣,同时也有这个能力。如果孩子们抱怨说每人一百太少,你就每人发给他两百,两百不行就一千或者两万——谁让你们把孩子们教育成一群货币拜物教信徒呢?担心通胀?大可不必!第一,那是早晚的事情;第二,到时候你按一下RESET,收回旧币重新发行一套新币不就万事大吉了。

至于发给孩子们的钱在他们之间怎么交换使用、财政当局这个老大会不会像一个哥哥姐姐的样子照顾厂商居民这些弟妹,把自己所得的一份儿分一点给更需要钱的弟妹,那都是另一码事儿了。

 

与经济有关的理论很多,比如什么关于股市的“茶叶蛋理论”,什么关于国资的“冰棍理论”等等,如果有哪位要引用本帖,记得加上注释,这叫做钱皮“关于货币的‘压岁钱理论’”。

二维码

扫码加我 拉你入群

请注明:姓名-公司-职位

以便审核进群资格,未注明则拒绝

关键词:压岁钱理论 货币发行 压岁钱 西方经济学的终结 Finance 货币发行 压岁钱理论 原创

沙发
戚华建 发表于 2009-1-8 14:06:00 |只看作者 |坛友微信交流群

张先生,请您看看我在这里的《资本、货币、银行与自由经济》一文,您就知道您的理论错在哪里了。

——货币不是财富,货币(这里指纸币)没有价值,社会上不是用于经济交换流通所需的货币越多,“货币灾难”就越严重。——所以,离开——借贷平衡——的“发行货币”的理论和观点都是错误的。

给我一个诺贝儿经济学奖,我是不要的。

使用道具

藤椅
张建平 在职认证  发表于 2009-1-8 22:13:00 |只看作者 |坛友微信交流群

这里涉及到问题的层面以及对“财富”二字的定义。

你必须解释货币收入对于居民意味着什么、国家的外汇储备意味着什么、“有价证券”之“价”意味着什么等等这些问题。

货币(不论是贵金属还是纸币),在经济学里更应该当作商品看待,我们不能够说商品没有价值。

使用道具

板凳
mnzhang 发表于 2010-12-18 11:34:15 |只看作者 |坛友微信交流群
很好的基础读物:http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/monetarypolicy/pdf/qe-pamphlet.pdf

China Vow to Ensure Stable, Healthy Economy in 2011

China will enhance and improve macro-economic regulation to ensure stable and healthy economic development next year, said a statement released Sunday after the annual Central Economic Work Conference.

Next year's macro-regulation should basically be proactive, stable, prudent and flexible, the statement said.

The focus will be better handling the relationship between stable and relatively fast economic development, economic restructuring and inflation expectations in an active and stable way, it said.

Participants at the three-day conference, one of China's most important economic-policy-making events, agreed to exert more efforts to keep prices stable next year.

They also agreed to accelerate the strategic transformation of the economic development pattern in order to make economic development more coordinated, sustainable and reliant on the domestic economy.

China's economy grew 9.6 percent year on year in the third quarter this year, slowing from the 10.3-percent increase in the second quarter and 11.9-percent surge in the first quarter.

Inflation picked up to a 28-month high of 5.1 percent in November, as bank lending looked certain to exceed the 7.5-trillion-yuan full-year target the government set at the start of the year.

Similarly, growth in the broad money supply (M2) - cash in circulation and all deposits - will surpass the government's full-year target of 17 percent.

Moreover, the U.S. Federal Reserve's second round of quantitative easing has increased the risk of imported inflation.

To curb inflation and soak up excessive liquidity, the country's central bank has raised banks' reserve requirement ratio six times this year. It also lifted the benchmark lending and deposit rates on Oct. 20, the first such move in nearly three years.

The meeting reaffirmed to boost farm produce supply through the development of modern agriculture in 2011, and clamp down on price speculation which is largely blamed for hiking prices.

The statement said the country will mainly employ economic and legal means, with administrative measures used when necessary, to keep the overall prices "basically stable".

On Dec. 3, China said it will shift its monetary policy stance in 2011 to "prudent" from "relatively loose."

"Credit should go to the real economy, especially the agricultural sector and small business," the statement said.

The meeting reaffirmed the continuation of the government's proactive fiscal policy.

Gao Peiyong, a researcher with the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, said a combination of proactive fiscal policy and a prudent monetary policy underscore the complications of the current economic situation.

"Macro-regulation has various goals. One is preventing the economy being affected by the global financial crisis. Another is curbing inflation. The situation is more complicated than before," he said.

The meeting also stressed steady growth in fiscal revenue, and austerity in government administrative expenditure, adding that local governments should strengthen debt management efforts.

China's fiscal revenue growth slowed to 12.2 percent in the third quarter this year from an increase of 22.7 percent in the second quarter and 34 percent in the first quarter.

Ma Haitao, a professor with the Central University of Finance and Economics, said the government is expected to face tight fiscal conditions next year, and local governments' debt deserves more attention to prevent it from spreading.

The statement also said the world's economy is likely to resume growing next year, though many uncertainties will remain.

"The global financial crisis had a significant impact on the global economy and the world economic order is undergoing profound and complicated change," it said.

Participants at the meeting agreed China's stable economic development would encounter a complicated situation next year, with many challenges and difficulties.

The uncertainties for Chinese economy include: the grain harvest and farmers' income; increased pressure to adjust the economic structure; resource and environment bottlenecks; the challenging task of improving people's livelihood and guaranteeing social stability.

The statement urged local authorities to be rational when making development targets, avoid blind pursuit of high growth rates and focus more on improving the quality and efficiency of growth as well as boosting employment and improving the public's standards of living.

At the meeting, it was agreed to make more efforts to boost consumer spending, check industries with excess capacity, upgrade the traditional manufacturing sector and strengthen the service industry.

"Earnest efforts should be made to develop the emerging strategic industries and to strengthen energy-saving and emission-reduction efforts," the statement said.

"China will further improve the Renminbi's exchange rate formation mechanism and keep the yuan basically stable and at a reasonable and balanced level," it said.

In 2011, the start of China's 12th Five-year Program (2011-2015), China will make concrete efforts to improve people's living standards, it said. The efforts will go to promoting improvements in education, cultural undertakings, health-care system reform, boosting employment, accelerating the construction of affordable housing and building a social security system that will cover both urban and rural residents.

The statement also said the country will maintain its mutually-beneficial opening-up strategy. "The country will continue to lay equal stress on imports and exports, as well as the attraction of foreign investment and making investments abroad."

It was decided at the meeting that the country will increase imports next year and make imports play an important role in the country's drive to rebalance the national economy, according to the statement.

The statement also said it is imperative to study and formulate a guideline on income distribution reform as an effort to prevent the further widening of the wealth gap.

The People's Daily, the flagship newspaper of the Communist Party of China, said in an editorial to be published on Monday, that the meeting was very meaningful for assuring a good start of the 12th Five-year Program.

The article called for national efforts to promote long-term stable and relatively fast economic development and social stability.

http://english.cri.cn/6909/2010/12/12/2743s609747.htm

使用道具

您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 我要注册

本版微信群
加JingGuanBbs
拉您进交流群

京ICP备16021002-2号 京B2-20170662号 京公网安备 11010802022788号 论坛法律顾问:王进律师 知识产权保护声明   免责及隐私声明

GMT+8, 2024-5-2 02:23