发帖
雷达卡
| 1、技术贡献、证据 2、切忌打击面太广、针对的问题多，切入点不能超过2个 3、知道你的敌人是谁 4、选题 5、实验结果、说服力 6、好的前言 7、相关工作、引用（该期刊） 8、修改文章（详细说明各点） 9、宽容态度、坚韧不拔 九条信息最重要 1、注意你的贡献，说明你的证据 2、idea有两种： ----Your technique solves a problem for the first time第一次，在某一点上第一次，革命性的，创造性的 ----如果不是第一次，Your technique performs better,in one or more of the the following dimensions: 1)Behaviour 效果比他好 2)Coverage 覆盖面广 3)Efficiency 速度快、占用空间少 4)Useability:Users find X easier to use than its rivals 使用方便 You should avoid claiming too many dimensions but one or two with in-depth evidence. 技术贡献不能多，要针对性，更深入。做得更加深入，切忌打击面广，别人反驳更多。 论文的架构（typical structure of a research paper）： title: Catchy and indicative of your research contribution Catchy 引入注目 indicative 特殊性 题目越长，被拒的可能性越高：例如：爱因斯坦提出“相对论”，就三个字，接下来就是“相对论的能量公式”字多了 indicative----说文章的大意，不要太抽象。例如：计算理论---太抽象了 abstract:A summary of the research problem,your chaim,and the evidence 以上三部分 introduce:将abstract中的A summary 的两三句话展开 1）motivation 动机 2)significance 意义 3）an outline of the rest of the paper Related work: 1) A critical review 评判 几大典型算法，各存在什么问题 2）我们的方法对于第一类问题怎么解决，对于第二类问题怎么解决 （批判别人，显出自己） 主编看摘要、前言就基本判决 Problem statement and algorithm design:Explain your ideas in detail Evaluation:evidence to support the claim of your research contribution ---unless you can provide proofs for a theoretical on theorems,experimental results and always expected Conclusion:画龙点睛、说你发出文章之后，此刻正在做的，接下来要做的，实验中还有哪些值得接着做的。 How to write and publish Research papers for the premier forums 国外期刊没有长度限制，这是和国内的期刊，例如“计算机学报”有区别 what to know and how to write a top-quality paper 前言最重要，能给审稿人留下印象，就是成功的一半了 1、A promising topic (一个有前途的主题) 2、A convincing case （让人信服的例证） 3、In-depth analysis of empirical results(经验结果的深度分析（例如，经验值、参数的设定）) 4、the most important part:the introduction (最重要的部分，前言) Scientific Paper的撰写（这类论文需要有自己的想法，不是综述文章，如review） Why write a scientific paper 1、Advance knowledge in your research field with evidence 有证据表明，在你研究的领域有了提高/前进 2、Explain your ideas and make them accessible to others 介绍你的主意，使他人理解 3、Two key components in a research paper --An explicit claim on your contribution on a research problem 针对某个研究问题，直接陈述你的贡献(自己做的工作要写出来) --Your contribution can possibly be a refutation of a hypothesis on the research problem 针对某个研究问题，你的贡献有可能被通过假设来驳斥。例如：你这么做，会不会造成数据丢失（在数据挖掘领域） 光有想法不行，要证明你的想法正确 What to know before you write 1.考虑读者是谁：根据所投的期刊 To whom are you writing?why will they be reading your writing? 2.Assess the purpose:What should the reader take away? 让读者带走什么 3.Read other people's writing from the forums that you are targeting 从要投的那个期刊上去找相关文章参考 4.Know your enemy:Check who are on the program committee or editorial board,and cite their relevant work with due credit 找编委的文章来参考，毕竟他们在这领域很牛 5.Follow the rules----length limits,formatting standards,etc 投会议，长度多长，可能自动放入一堆，直到截至时，才告诉你论文过长 choose a promising topic 与外国教授（有名的）交流，看他们的论文，问他们在这方面有什么新的进展，是否有往下做的可能 10 challenging problems -----How to present a convincing case? -----How are your ideas significant (to justify a paper)? -----Some ideas are so simple that have been used many times W/O being published. -----Is all related work referenced and reviewed? 要与主流的方法进行比较 -----Are the comparative studies with previous work convincing? ----Have your system been implemented and used,and if so what did it demonstrate from the real world. -----Enough details for your experiment setting.(so that other researchers can verify and improve your results) -----What were the alternatives considered at various points of your experiments?Why and how have you made the choices for your experiments? (让别人直到你各种实验参数设置都考虑到了) consistent and conclusive 一致性和总结性 -----Can you fine-tune some key parameters to get better or worse results?If so,use figures and tables to show their impacts on your system performances 公平比较，要别人最佳的情况进行比较 ------How do the experimental results correspond to the motivation of the paper? ------What have you found surprising and tried to avoid in these experiments?How generally applicable are these lessons? 如果论文是8页纸，那么4页是做实验的。 ------The 1/3-2/3 Rule from a reviewer's perspective. 如果论文是8页纸，那么前言占1页 1） 1/3 time to read your introduction and make a decision 2) Remaining 2/3 time to find evidence for the decision -----A good introduction with a good motivation is half of your success. what to cover in the introduction ----The research problem ----The movivation of your research on the research problem ----The claim of your contribution -----A summary of your evidence to support your claim -----The significance of your contribution -----An outline of the rest of the paper Most important of all:the uniqueness of you research in the field! 最佳投稿方式： 首先投顶级的会议，若被录用，则对论文进行扩展，在题名上加“*”，说明：论文缩写版已经被某国际会议录用，投国际期刊 这么做好处：1、让编审注意，这篇论文已经在国际会议上录用，说明有价值，值得细看； 2、防止一稿多投。提前告诉 Your work has to be (1)technically sound (2)relevant (3)original (4)significant 起死回生（文章被拒之后） 期刊----（题目，摘要）---主编---》副编-听取意见-》审稿人（reviewers） 会议-----主席--》副主席---》程序主席---》程序委员会（一般为审稿人） 如何处理返回意见（How to deal with handling Editors） 1.有礼貌 Be polite,but to the point 2.Ask for a change,if a clearly unfair case 把副主编换了，告诉主编，让别的副主编来审稿，只要你有道理 如果有3个人审稿，2个人认为不好，则不行。如果一个说好，一个说不好，对比，比较他们的意见 ----Try every effort to address every concert 提供他们点对点的修改意见 有的审稿者的意见不能从 Use other reviewers's comments to disagree with the regative ones How to deal with "arregant" and "ignorant" reviewers ---if there is no chance to win them over,provide a gentle statement for the "unreasonable"criticisms that you are not addressing ---You should still try and resolve some of their comments ---your attitude towards the reviewers' comments is important ----all reviewers will read your statement of changes,and an accommodating approach is useful. |
受教育了，谢谢
京公网安备 11010802022788号
