APPLIED ECONOMICS LETTERS期刊回复求助

x948936710 发表于 2021-5-27 10:31
已被录用，投稿环节有疑问的欢迎提问

您好，方便加个联系方式吗？我微信17661213351  我投稿后收到修改意见，但有些疑问

mev6883203 发表于 2022-7-14 00:01
我的论文在本月经过一次大修，已经重新提交。提交第四天，未收到录用。
请问①邮件内容表示是修后重审吗 ...

你好，可以咨询一下Applied Economics Letters的投稿吗，我投稿后，收到了跟您内容差不多的邮件，如下。这是要求大改吗，因为审稿意见全是关于摘要、引言和结论的，完全没有提到实证，是审稿人觉得我引言太差了，想让我先改引言吗，还没看到实证？
I have now received a report on your paper in which the referee makes a number of recommendations for improvement. Whilst I am unable to accept the paper for publication in its present version, therefore, I should be happy to reconsider it if you were to revise it carefully along the lines suggested by the referee.  I note that some of the revisions suggested by the referee are quite substantial and I hope that you will be willing to undertake this extra work, since I otherwise shall be unable to reconsider the paper.

In accordance with our format-free submission policy, an editable version of the article must be supplied at the revision stage. Please submit your revised manuscript files in an editable file format.

romanann 发表于 2024-1-8 14:54
想请教下LZ，
1，从哪里可以分辨是不是major revision呀？（这句话？I note that some of the revisions  ...

你好，可以咨询一下Applied Economics Letters的投稿吗，我投稿后，收到了跟您内容差不多的邮件，如下。这是要求大改吗，因为审稿意见全是关于摘要、引言和结论的，完全没有提到实证，是审稿人觉得我引言太差了，想让我先改引言吗，还没看到实证？
I have now received a report on your paper in which the referee makes a number of recommendations for improvement. Whilst I am unable to accept the paper for publication in its present version, therefore, I should be happy to reconsider it if you were to revise it carefully along the lines suggested by the referee.  I note that some of the revisions suggested by the referee are quite substantial and I hope that you will be willing to undertake this extra work, since I otherwise shall be unable to reconsider the paper.

In accordance with our format-free submission policy, an editable version of the article must be supplied at the revision stage. Please submit your revised manuscript files in an editable file format.

romanann 发表于 2024-1-8 14:54
想请教下LZ，
1，从哪里可以分辨是不是major revision呀？（这句话？I note that some of the revisions  ...

我刚收到返修意见，有跟您一样的疑问，可以交流一下吗

您好，请问您当时外审意见回来后decision pending多久后收到了修改意见啊？