2004最新经济学学科大学排名[转载]

是 否 +2 论坛币

k人 参与回答

经管之家送您一份

应届毕业生专属福利!

求职就业群

赵安豆老师微信：zhaoandou666

经管之家联合CDA

送您一个全额奖学金名额~ !

立即领取

感谢您参与论坛问题回答

经管之家送您两个论坛币！

+2 论坛币

No.1 Economics Ranking, Overall [转载]

Economics Ranking, Overall The rankings reflect adjusted page counts in the forty most-cited economics journals (based on Kalaitzidakis et al., EER, 2002; see below) between 1993 and 2003. Some articles were ruled out: those of length three pages or less, errata and corrigenda, and those by authors who had fewer than three publications in that period. (The rationale for the latter exclusion is that the last published affiliation of very infrequent authors is likely to be outdated.) Co-author scores are calculated for every article from page count adjusted for: (1) "quality" category of the journal, (2) number of co-authors, (3) recency. An institution's score is the sum of the aggregated co-author scores of those who named the institution as their first affiliation in their most recent publication. Subfield rankings use the same procedure after grouping articles by the first-given JEL classification. The length of the lists as they are displayed depends on a cut-off score; since the cut-off is the same for all subfields, the number of ranks shown roughly correlates with the "size" of the subfield. As some correspondents have pointed out, there are important specialty journals missing from the list of journals. This is a problem when ranking departments in areas like economic history, where a large share of key research is published in these journals. In time, I will amend the journal list in certain subfields on a case-by-case basis and revise these specialty rankings. Universities 1 Harvard U Cambridge, USA 100.0 2 U Chicago Chicago, USA 89.7 3 MIT Cambridge, USA 73.7 4 U California, Berkeley Berkeley, USA 71.9 5 Northwestern U Evanston, USA 70.2 6 Stanford U Palo Alto, USA 65.6 7 Princeton U Princeton, USA 64.7 8 U Pennsylvania Philadelphia, USA 62.6 9 NYU New York, USA 58.9 10 Yale U New Haven, USA 58.2 11 London School of Economics London, UK 51.5 12 UCLA Los Angeles, USA 49.6 13 Columbia U New York, USA 48.1 14 U Wisconsin Madison, USA 43.8 15 U Minnesota St Paul, USA 35.8 16 U Michigan Ann Arbor, USA 35.2 17 Cornell U Ithaca, USA 34.9 18 University College London London, UK 34.2 19 Tel Aviv U Tel Aviv, Israel 33.6 20 Brown U Providence, USA 33.6 21 U California, San Diego La Jolla, USA 32.9 22 U Sciences Sociales Toulouse I Toulouse, France 32.0 23 U Rochester Rochester, USA 31.9 24 U Texas Austin, USA 31.5 25 U Maryland College Park, USA 31.1 26 U Illinois Urbana-Champaign, USA 30.6 27 Tilburg U Tilburg, Netherlands 28.5 28 Ohio State U Columbus, Ohio 28.5 29 U British Columbia Vancouver, Canada 27.1 30 Cal Tech Pasadena, USA 24.6 31 Carnegie Mellon U Pittsburgh, USA 24.2 32 Hebrew U Jerusalem, Israel 23.8 33 Pennsylvania State U State College, Pennsylvania 23.6 34 Boston U Boston, USA 23.4 35 U California, Davis Davis, USA 23.2 36 U Toronto Toronto, Canada 22.6 37 U Southern California Los Angeles, USA 22.5 38 U Amsterdam Amsterdam, Netherlands 22.2 39 Duke U Durham (NC), USA 22.1 40 U Warwick Warwick, UK 21.3 41 U Essex Colchester, UK 21.2 42 Texas A&M U College Station, USA 21.0 43 Michigan State U East Lansing, USA 20.9 44 U Carlos III Madrid Madrid, Spain 20.7 45 U Cambridge Cambridge, UK 19.7 46 Johns Hopkins U Baltimore, USA 19.4 47 U Copenhagen Copenhagen, Denmark 19.0 48 U Virginia Charlottesville, USA 18.8 49 Arizona State U Tempe, USA 18.5 50 U Pompeu Fabra Barcelona, Spain 18.4 51 Oxford U Oxford, UK 18.2 52 U Catholique Louvain Leuven, Belgium 18.0 53 U Montreal Montreal, Canada 17.9 54 Boston College Chestnut Hill, USA 17.8 55 U North Carolina Chapel Hill, USA 17.6 56 Rutgers U New Brunswick, USA 17.3 57 U Bonn Bonn, Germany 16.8 58 U Autonoma Barcelona Barcelona, Spain 15.8 59 Maastricht U Maastricht, Netherlands 15.8 60 U Washington Seattle, USA 15.7 61 Vanderbilt U Nashville, USA 15.6 62 Indiana U Bloomington, USA 15.3 63 Washington U St Louis, USA 15.1 64 U Paris I Sorbonne Paris, France 14.4 65 U Arizona Tucson, USA 14.0 66 Dartmouth College Hanover, USA 14.0 67 European U Institute Florence, Italy 14.0 68 Stockholm U Stockholm, Sweden 13.9 69 Hong Kong U Science & Technology Hong Kong, China 13.8 70 Georgetown U Washington, USA 13.8 71 Stockholm School of Economics Stockholm, Sweden 13.3 72 Iowa State U Ames, Iowa 13.3 73 U Pittsburgh Pittsburgh, USA 13.2 74 U Iowa Iowa City, USA 13.1 75 Queen's U (Can) Kingston, Canada 13.0 76 U York (UK) York, UK 12.8 77 Purdue U West Lafayette, USA 12.6 78 U Western Ontario London, Canada 12.0 79 Rice U Houston, USA 12.0 80 U California, Santa Barbara Santa Barbara, USA 11.6 81 U California, Irvine Irvine, USA 11.4 82 U Nottingham Nottingham, UK 11.4 83 Chinese U Hong Kong Hong Kong, China 11.3 84 Vrije U Amsterdam, Netherlands 11.0 85 Ecole National Ponts et Chaussees Paris, France 10.4 86 U Zurich Zurich, Switzerland 10.0 87 Virginia Tech Blacksburg, Virginia 10.0 88 U Vienna Vienna, Austria 10.0 89 Ben Gurion U of the Negev Beersheba, Israel 9.7 90 U Florida Gainesville, Florida 9.6 91 Humboldt U Berlin Berlin, Germany 9.4 92 Southern Methodist U Dallas, USA 9.4 93 U Alicante Alicante, Spain 9.3 94 North Carolina State U Raleigh, USA 8.9 95 U Tokyo Tokyo, Japan 8.7 96 U Bristol Bristol, UK 8.7 97 Syracuse U Syracuse, USA 8.7 98 U Southampton Southampton, UK 8.5 99 Osaka U Osaka, Japan 8.5 100 U Houston Houston, USA 8.2 101 U Mannheim Mannheim, Germany 8.2 102 Queen Mary College U London London, UK 8.1 103 U Melbourne Melbourne, Australia 8.0 104 Technion - Israel Institute of Technology Haifa, Israel 8.0 105 Erasmus U Rotterdam Rotterdam, Netherlands 7.9 106 Bar Ilan U Ramat Gan, Israel 7.9 107 National U Singapore Singapore, Singapore 7.9 108 Indian Statistical Institute New Delhi, India 7.8 109 U Cergy-Pontoise Cergy-Pontoise, France 7.7 110 U Oslo Oslo, Norway 7.7 111 U Colorado Boulder, USA 7.7 112 U Birmingham Birmingham, UK 7.5 113 George Washington U Washington, USA 7.5 114 INSEAD Fontainebleau, France 7.4 115 McGill U Montreal, Canada 7.4 116 Bocconi U Milan, Italy 7.3 117 U Helsinki Helsinki, Finland 7.1 118 U Aix-Marseille II - U Mediterranee Marseille, France 7.1 119 London Business School London, UK 7.1 120 Kobe U Kobe, Japan 6.9 121 SUNY Albany Albany, USA 6.9 122 Australian National U Canberra, Australia 6.9 123 U Notre Dame (USA) South Bend, USA 6.8 124 U Bielefeld Bielefeld, Germany 6.6 125 U Libre Bruxelles Brussels, Belgium 5.2 126 U Turin Turin, Italy 6.4 127 U Edinburgh Edinburgh, UK 6.3 128 U Haifa Haifa, Israel 6.3 129 U Laval Ste Foy, Canada 6.2 130 U New South Wales Sydney, Australia 6.2 131 U California, Santa Cruz Santa Cruz, USA 6.1 132 U Exeter Exeter, UK 5.9 133 U Quebec Montreal, Canada 5.9 134 U Pais Vasco San Sebastian, Spain 5.9 135 Simon Fraser U Burnaby, Canada 5.8 136 Uppsala U Uppsala, Sweden 5.8 137 U Munich Munich, Germany 5.8 138 U Oregon Eugene, USA 5.8 139 York U (Toronto) Toronto, Canada 5.7 140 Instituto Tecnologico Autonomo de Mexico (ITAM) Mexico City, Mexico 5.7 141 U Manchester Manchester, UK 5.7 142 U Geneva / Graduate Institute of International Studies (HEI) Geneva, Switzerland 4.3 143 Tufts U Mexico City, Mexico 5.6 144 U Kentucky Medford, USA 5.6 145 Ecole Polytechnique Paris, France 5.5 146 U California, Riverside Riverside, California 5.4 147 Birkbeck College U London London, UK 5.4 148 Seoul National U Seoul, Korea 5.4 149 SUNY Stony Brook Stony Brook, USA 5.3 150 Academia Sinica Taipei, Taiwan 5.3 151 U Georgia Athens (GA), USA 5.3 152 Bilkent U Ankara, Turkey 5.2 153 U Alabama Tuscaloosa, USA 5.2 154 U Cyprus Nicosia, Cyprus 5.2 155 University of Missouri Columbia (MO), USA 5.0 156 University College Dublin Dublin, Ireland 5.0 157 Helsinki School of Economics Helsinki, Finland 4.9 158 Brigham Young U Provo, USA 4.9 159 Monash U Melbourne, Australia 4.9 160 Aarhus U Aarhus, Denmark 4.8 161 Hautes Etudes Commerciales (HEC), Jouy-en Josas Paris, France 1.8 162 Georgia State U Atlanta, USA 4.8 163 National Taiwan U Taipei, Taiwan 4.7 164 Hitotsubashi U Tokyo, Japan 4.6 165 McMaster U Hamilton, Canada 3.8 166 U Paris IX Dauphine Paris, France 4.5 167 U Glasgow Glasgow, UK 4.5 168 College of William & Mary Williamsburg, Virginia 4.5 169 U Groningen Groningen, Netherlands 4.5 170 Ewha U Seoul, Korea 4.5 171 U Hong Kong Hong Kong, China 4.5 172 City U Hong Kong Hong Kong, China 4.5 173 Centro des Estudios Monetarios y Financieros (CEMFI) Madrid, Spain 4.4 174 U Illinois, Chicago Chicago, USA 4.4 175 U Colorado, Denver Denver, USA 4.3 176 U Wales, Cardiff Cardiff, UK 4.3 177 U Tsukuba Tsukuba, Japan 4.2 178 Carleton U Ottawa, Canada 4.2 179 U Miami Miami, USA 4.1 180 Royal Holloway College U London Egham, UK 4.1 181 Indiana U - Purdue U Indianapolis, USA 4.1 182 Florida International U Miami, USA 4.0 183 U Venice Venice, Italy 4.0 184 Emory U Atlanta, USA 4.0 185 U Bologna Bologna, Italy 4.0 186 U Alberta Edmonton, Canada 4.0 187 U Liverpool Liverpool, UK 4.0 188 U Waterloo Waterloo, Canada 4.0 189 Ecole Hautes Etudes Sciences Sociales (EHESS) Paris, France 4.0 190 U Massachusetts Amherst, USA 3.9 191 Kyoto U Kyoto, Japan 3.9 192 Tulane U New Orleans, USA 3.9 193 U Paris X Nanterre Paris, France 3.9 194 Freie U Berlin Berlin, Germany 3.9 195 Concordia U Montreal, Canada 3.8 196 U Leicester Leicester, UK 3.8 197 Louisiana State U Baton Rouge, USA 3.8 198 Claremont Graduate U / Claremont Colleges Claremont, USA 3.7 199 U Notre Dame (Bel) Namur, Belgium 3.6 200 U Valencia Valencia, Spain 3.6 201 U East Anglia Norwich, UK 3.6 202 U Nova Lisbon Lisbon, Portugal 3.5 203 HEC Montreal Montreal, Canada 3.5 204 Instituto Nacional Matematica Pura & Aplicada (IMPA) Rio, Brazil 3.5 205 U Mississippi Oxford (MS), USA 3.5 206 U Windsor Windsor, Canada 3.4 207 U Wyoming Laramie, USA 3.3 208 Florida State U Tallahassee, USA 3.3 209 Norwegian School of Economics & Business Administration Bergen, Norway 3.2 210 Oregon State U Corvallis, USA 3.2 211 U Louis Pasteur Strasbourg, France 2.5 212 U Texas, Dallas Dallas, USA 3.2 213 SUNY Binghamton Binghamton, USA 3.2 214 Lund U Lund, Sweden 3.1 215 Santa Clara U Santa Clara, USA 3.1 216 Clemson U Clemson, USA 3.1 217 U Lausanne Lausanne, Switzerland 3.0 218 Koc U Istanbul, Turkey 3.0 219 City U London London, UK 3.0 220 U St Gallen St Gallen, Switzerland 3.0 221 Athens U Economics & Business Athens, Greece 3.0 222 U Modena Modena, Italy 3.0 223 U Delaware Newark (DE), USA 3.0 224 U Queensland Brisbane, Australia 3.0 225 American U Washington, USA 2.9 226 Kansas State U Manhattan (KS), USA 2.9 227 U Strathclyde Glasgow, UK 2.9 228 U St Andrews St Andrews, UK 2.9 229 U Heidelberg Heidelberg, Germany 2.9 230 U Chile Santiago, Chile 2.8 231 U Bordeaux IV Montesquieu Bordeaux, France 2.8 232 Tohoku U Sendai, Japan 2.8 233 U Guelph Guelph, Canada 2.8 234 U Kent Canterbury, UK 2.7 235 CUNY New York, USA 2.7 236 U Caen Caen, France 2.7 237 U Bergen Bergen, Norway 2.7 238 U Murcia Murcia, Spain 2.6 239 Washington State U Spokane, USA 2.6 240 U Kansas Lawrence, USA 2.6 241 U South Carolina Columbia (SC), USA 2.6 242 West Virginia U Morgantown, USA 2.6 243 Southern Illinois U Carbondale, USA 2.5 244 Wilfrid Laurier U Waterloo, Canada 2.5 245 Sogang U Seoul, Korea 1.7 246 U Cologne Cologne, Germany 2.5 247 Ecole Normale Superieure Paris, France 2.5 248 Victoria U Wellington Wellington, New Zealand 2.5 249 Imperial College U London London, UK 2.5 250 U Osnabruck Osnabruck, Germany 2.4 251 Case Western Reserve U Cleveland, USA 2.4 252 Korea U Seoul, Korea 2.4 253 Jawaharlal Nehru U New Delhi, India 2.3 254 Goethe U Frankfurt Frankfurt (Main), Germany 2.3 255 U Auckland Auckland, New Zealand 2.3 256 U Newcastle upon Tyne Newcastle upon Tyne, UK 1.2 257 U Nevada, Las Vegas Las Vegas, USA 2.3 258 SUNY Buffalo Buffalo, USA 2.3 259 Tokyo Metropolitan U Tokyo, Japan 2.3 260 Brunel U London, UK 2.3 261 U Torcuato Di Tella Buenos Aires, Argentina 2.2 262 Ecole National Statistique & Adminstration Economique (ENSAE) Malakoff, France 2.2 263 U Dortmund Dortmund, Germany 2.2 264 George Mason U Fairfax, USA 2.2 265 U Salerno Salerno, Italy 2.2 266 Auburn U Auburn, USA 2.2 267 U Western Australia Perth, Australia 2.2 268 U Sydney Sydney, Australia 2.2 269 Montana State U Bozeman, USA 2.2 270 Virginia Commonwealth U Richmond, USA 2.2 271 U Basel Basel, Switzerland 2.2 272 U Connecticut Storrs, USA 2.2 273 U Florence Florence, Italy 2.2 274 U Oklahoma Norman, USA 2.1 275 Institute for Advanced Studies, Vienna Vienna, Austria 2.1 276 U Victoria Victoria, Canada 2.1 277 U Constance Constance, Germany 2.1 278 U Padua Padua, Italy 2.0 279 National Chengchi U Taipei, Taiwan 2.0 280 U Vigo Vigo, Spain 2.0 281 U Utrecht Utrecht, Netherlands 2.0 282 Brandeis U Waltham, USA 2.0 283 U Rome I La Sapienza Rome, Italy 2.0 284 U Reading Reading, UK 1.9 285 U Karlsruhe Karlsruhe, Germany 1.9 286 Technical U Dresden Dresden, Germany 1.9 287 Gotenborg U Gotenborg, Sweden 1.9 288 U Wisconsin, Milwaukee Milwaukee, USA 1.9 289 Dalhousie U Halifax, Canada 1.9 290 U Surrey Guildford, UK 1.9 291 U Nebraska Lincoln, USA 1.8 292 Wellesley College Wellesley, USA 1.8 293 Peking U Peking, China 1.8 294 U New Mexico Albuquerque, USA 1.8 295 Catholic U Milan Milan, Italy 1.8 296 Catholic U Portugal Lisbon, Portugal 1.8 297 Utah State U Logan, USA 1.8 298 U Kiel Kiel, Germany 1.7 299 U North Carolina, Greensboro Greensboro, USA 1.7 300 U Zaragoza Zaragoza, Spain 1.7 301 Wayne State U Detroit, USA 1.7 302 U Sao Paulo Sao Paolo, Brazil 1.7 303 Keele U Keele, UK 1.7 304 Keio U Tokyo, Japan 1.6 305 U Technology, Sydney Sydney, Australia 1.6 306 Swarthmore College Swarthmore, USA 1.6 307 Vienna U Technology Vienna, Austria 1.6 308 Kagawa U Takamatsu, Japan 1.6 309 U Sussex Brighton, UK 1.6 310 Fordham U New York, USA 1.5 311 California State U, Fullerton Fullerton, USA 1.5 312 Williams College Williamtown, USA 1.5 313 DePaul U Chicago, USA 1.5 314 U Pau Pau, France 1.5 315 Tokyo International U Tokyo, Japan 1.5 316 U Durham Durham, UK 1.5 317 U Paris VI Pierre & Marie Curie Paris, France 1.5 318 Temple U Philadelphia, USA 1.5 319 Norwegian School of Management Sandvika, Norway 1.5 320 Queen's U Belfast Belfast, UK 1.5 321 Technical U Eindhoven Eindhoven, Netherlands 1.5 322 Yokohama National U Yokohama, Japan 1.5 Noneducational Research Institutions 1 World Bank Washington, USA 100.0 2 International Monetary Fund (IMF) Washington, USA 75.2 3 Federal Reserve System Board of Governors Washington, USA 63.6 4 Federal Reserve Bank of New York New York, USA 30.6 5 Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago Chicago, USA 24.9 6 US Dept Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics Washington, USA 15.6 7 Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Minneapolis, USA 15.5 8 Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco San Francisco, USA 13.7 9 Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond Richmond, USA 12.7 10 US Dept Treasury / Office of Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) Washington, USA 12.5 11 Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Cleveland, USA 12.3 12 RAND Corporation Santa Monica (CA), USA 11.9 13 Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City Kansas City, USA 11.6 14 Federal Reserve Bank of Boston Boston, USA 10.9 15 Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta Atlanta, USA 10.8 16 Federal Reserve Bank of St Louis St Louis, USA 10.1 17 Bank of England London, UK 9.5 18 US Dept Agriculture, Economic Research Service Washington, USA 8.1 19 Banco de Espana Madrid, Spain 7.4 20 Statistics Norway Oslo, Norway 7.3 21 Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas Dallas, USA 7.3 22 Resources for the Future Washington, USA 7.2 23 Brookings Institution Washington, USA 6.8 24 National Institute of Econ & Social Research London, UK 6.3 25 Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia Philadelphia, USA 5.5 26 Bell Laboratories Murray Hill (NJ), USA 5.5 27 American Enterprise Institute Washington, USA 5.4 28 Urban Institute Washington, USA 5.4 29 International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) Washington, USA 5.1 30 Statistics Canada Ottawa, Canada 4.7 31 Citigroup New York, USA 4.5 32 Deutsche Bank Frankfurt, Germany 4.0 33 Banque de France Paris, France 3.9 34 Finnish Forest Research Institute Helsinki, Finland 3.8 35 Bank of Canada Ottawa, Canada 3.8 36 Institute for International Economics Washington, USA 3.4 37 Inter-American Development Bank Washington, USA 3.3 38 European Central Bank Frankfurt, Germany 3.1 39 US Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) Washington, USA 2.8 40 US Dept Commerce, Bureau of the Census Washington, USA 2.7 41 Bank of Israel Tel Aviv, Israel 2.7 42 Charles River Associates Cambridge, USA 2.7 43 US Congressional Budget Office Washington, USA 2.6 44 Monitor Company Cambridge, USA 2.5 45 Xerox Palo Alto Research Center Palo Alto (CA), USA 2.3 46 Goldman-Sachs & Co New York, USA 2.2 47 Bank for International Settlements (BIS) Basel, Switzerland 2.2 48 US Dept Justice / Antitrust Division Washington, USA 2.2 49 Organismo Publico Valenciano de Investigacion Valencia, Spain 2.1 50 National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) Cambridge, USA 2.1 51 National Economic Research Associates New York, USA 2.1 52 W E Upjohn Institute for Employment Research Kalamazoo, USA 2.0 53 International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA) Laxenburg, Austria 1.9 54 Battelle Memorial Institute Seattle, USA 1.8 55 UD Dept Commerce, Federal Trade Commission Washington, USA 1.8 56 De Nederlandsche Bank Amsterdam, Netherlands 1.7 57 Banca d'Italia Rome, Italy 1.6 58 US Dept Commerce, Bureau of Econ Analysis (BEA) Washington, USA 1.6 59 Swiss National Bank Zurich, Switzerland 1.5 60 Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae) Washington, USA 1.5 Included journals and categories: (I) Econometrica, Journal of Economic Theory, Journal of Political Economy, Quarterly Journal of Economics, Review of Economic Studies; (II) Econometric Theory, Economic Theory, Games and Economic Behavior, International Journal of Game Theory, Journal of Business Economics and Statistics, Journal of Econometrics, Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, Journal of Mathematical Economics, Review Economics and Statistics, Social Choice and Welfare; (III) American Economic Review, Economic Journal, European Economic Review, International Economic Review, Journal of Economic Growth, Journal of Economic Literature, Journal of Economic Perspectives, Journal of Human Resources, Journal of Monetary Economics, Journal of Public Economics; (IV) American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Economic Inquiry, Economics Letters, Journal of Applied Econometrics, Journal of Development Economics, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, Journal of Financial Economics, Journal of International Economics, Journal of Labor Economics, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, Rand Journal of Economics, Scandinavian Journal of Economics, World Bank Economic Review. http://www.econphd.net/rank/rovall.htm

扫码加我 拉你入群

请注明：姓名-公司-职位

以便审核进群资格，未注明则拒绝

分享0 收藏1 回帖

关键词：新经济学 大学排名 经济学 新经济 Pennsylvania 经济学 大学 排名 学科

呵呵，尽管以前贴过了。还是支持一下。

牛津剑桥落后LSE那么多，而港大干脆落后科大和中大100名！图卢兹一大进步太快了，中国大陆就不说了。

以下是引用nie在2004-11-30 23:45:38的发言： 牛津剑桥落后LSE那么多，而港大干脆落后科大和中大100名！图卢兹一大进步太快了，中国大陆就不说了。

牛津、剑桥没有严格的课程训练，还是欧洲老的经济学教育模式。

而LSE、UCL、Toulouse I 、Tilburg U 、U Warwick 、U Carlos III Madrid 、U Pompeu Fabra这些学校都是采用美国模式，教学和研究与北美一流学校没有差别或相差不大。LSE、UCL、Toulouse I 的不少毕业生会取得美国好学校的教职。

U Paris I Sorbonne Paris————巴黎一大尽管总排名64，但其在General Equilibrium Theory 方面的排名绝对是前10名。

3.1. General Equilibrium Theory / Cooperative Games / Mathematical & Computational Economics JEL: C60-C63, C65, C67-C69, C71, D50-D52, D57-D59, D84

			Equiv Papers	Author Count
1	U California - Los Angeles	USA	6.8	9
2	Stanford U	USA	6.0	13
3	Tilburg U	Netherlands	5.1	16
4	U California - Berkeley	USA	4.9	6
5	U Illinois - Urbana-Champaign	USA	4.7	9
6	Columbia U	USA	4.3	7
7	U Paris I (Pantheon-Sorbonne)	France	4.1	10
8	Northwestern U	USA	4.1	8
9	Cornell U	USA	4.0	11
10	U Chicago	USA	4.0	10
11	Ecole National Ponts & Chaussees	France	2.9	2
12	Brown U	USA	2.8	6
13	Maastricht U	Netherlands	2.7	6
14	New York U (NYU)	USA	2.6	6
15	U California - Santa Barbara	USA	2.5	3
16	U Pennsylvania	USA	2.4	5
17	U Amsterdam	Netherlands	2.4	7
18	U Pais Vasco	Spain	2.3	10
19	Arizona State U	USA	2.3	4
20	Free U Amsterdam (Vrije U)	Netherlands	2.2	3
21	Yale U	USA	1.9	5
22	U Tsukuba	Japan	1.9	5
23	U Southern California	USA	1.9	6
24	Hebrew U	Israel	1.9	3
25	U Minnesota	USA	1.8	6
26	U California - Davis	USA	1.8	6
27	Rutgers U	USA	1.8	4
28	U Bielefeld	Germany	1.8	5
29	California Institute of Technology (Caltech)	USA	1.7	4
30	Purdue U	USA	1.7	3

2楼的mao8888888 朋友也许对Financial Economics 的排名更感兴趣一些。

http://www.econphd.net/rank/rfinec.htm

Rankings.

Financial Economics

econphd.net rankings 2004 © Christian Roessler

Tables may be freely cited and reproduced except for commercial purposes. Please do not post them elsewhere on the world wide web.

9. Subdiscipline Financial Economics JEL: G0-G3

			Equiv Papers	Author Count
1	U Chicago	USA	26.8	39
2	Harvard U	USA	23.8	38
3	U Pennsylvania	USA	18.8	35
4	New York U (NYU)	USA	16.0	45
5	Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)	USA	15.0	28
6	Northwestern U	USA	13.0	24
7	U California - Los Angeles	USA	11.8	27
8	Stanford U	USA	11.2	24
9	Princeton U	USA	9.8	17
10	Columbia U	USA	8.9	24
11	Ohio State U	USA	8.8	20
12	U Texas - Austin	USA	7.8	14
13	London School of Economics	UK	7.3	18
14	Duke U	USA	7.0	12
15	U Rochester	USA	6.1	11
16	U California - San Diego	USA	6.0	11
17	U Southern California	USA	6.0	14
18	U California - Berkeley	USA	5.6	18
19	U Illinois - Urbana-Champaign	USA	5.4	16
20	U Notre Dame	USA	5.1	12
21	Boston College	USA	5.0	12
22	Carnegie Mellon U	USA	5.0	15
23	U Toulouse I (Sciences Sociales)	France	4.9	11
24	U Michigan - Ann Arbor	USA	4.9	18
25	Yale U	USA	4.7	15
26	INSEAD	France	4.3	11
27	Purdue U	USA	4.3	12
28	London Business School	UK	4.3	14
29	U Florida	USA	4.2	9
30	Cornell U	USA	3.9	14
31	U Maryland - College Park	USA	3.8	13
32	U Minnesota	USA	3.8	9
33	California Institute of Technology (Caltech)	USA	3.7	8
34	U North Carolina - Chapel Hill	USA	3.7	10
35	Indiana U	USA	3.7	12
36	Penn State U	USA	3.3	12
37	U Iowa	USA	3.2	10
38	U British Columbia	Canada	3.2	12
39	U Washington	USA	3.1	10
40	U Autonoma Barcelona	Spain	3.1	9
41	U Wisconsin - Madison	USA	3.0	8
42	Iowa State U	USA	3.0	15
43	Emory U	USA	3.0	8
44	Boston U	USA	2.9	10
45	U Toronto	Canada	2.8	12
46	Rutgers U	USA	2.8	11
47	Arizona State U	USA	2.7	8
48	Dartmouth College	USA	2.7	6
49	Hebrew U	Israel	2.6	7
50	Chinese U Hong Kong	China	2.6	8
51	U California - Davis	USA	2.6	11
52	Tilburg U	Netherlands	2.6	15
53	Stockholm School of Economics	Sweden	2.5	5
54	Birkbeck College	UK	2.5	8
55	Michigan State U	USA	2.4	11
56	Oxford U	UK	2.4	9
57	HEC Montreal	Canada	2.3	6
58	Warwick U	UK	2.3	12
59	Washington U St Louis	USA	2.2	6
60	U Georgia	USA	2.2	14
61	Louisiana State U	USA	2.2	5
62	Georgetown U	USA	2.2	8
63	Rice U	USA	2.2	7
64	U Paris IX (Dauphine)	France	2.2	5
65	U Cambridge	UK	2.1	7
66	U Oregon	USA	2.0	4
67	Brown U	USA	2.0	7
68	Virginia Tech	USA	1.9	9
69	Hong Kong U Science & Technology (HKUST)	China	1.9	8
70	U Kentucky	USA	1.8	7
71	Johns Hopkins U	USA	1.8	4
72	Tel Aviv U	Israel	1.8	8
73	York U Toronto	Canada	1.7	7
74	Imperial College	UK	1.7	6
75	Vanderbilt U	USA	1.7	7
76	Santa Clara U	USA	1.7	4
77	U Amsterdam	Netherlands	1.6	6
78	Center for Monetary & Financial Studies (CEMFI)	Spain	1.6	4
79	U Salerno	Italy	1.6	2
80	Concordia U	Canada	1.5	9
81	U Virginia	USA	1.5	6
82	Queen's U	Canada	1.5	5
83	U Cyprus	Cyprus	1.5	4
84	U California - Irvine	USA	1.5	4
85	U Pompeu Fabra	Spain	1.5	4
86	U Vienna	Austria	1.5	4
87	U Arizona	USA	1.4	5
88	Norwegian School of Management	Norway	1.4	3
89	Tulane U	USA	1.4	4
90	City U New York (CUNY)	USA	1.4	5
91	KU Leuven	Belgium	1.4	8
92	U Paris I (Pantheon-Sorbonne)	France	1.3	6
93	U Pittsburgh	USA	1.3	4
94	City U London	UK	1.3	8
95	Free U Brussels (U Libre)	Belgium	1.3	3
96	U Lausanne	Switzerland	1.3	2
97	Erasmus U Rotterdam	Netherlands	1.3	7
98	U Munich (Ludwig-Maximilians-U)	Germany	1.3	8
99	Bar-Ilan U	Israel	1.3	5
100	U Edinburgh	UK	1.3	4
101	Brigham Young U	USA	1.3	5
102	U Western Ontario	Canada	1.2	4
103	Southern Methodist U	USA	1.2	5
104	U Laval	Canada	1.2	3
105	U Mannheim	Germany	1.1	4
106	Texas A&M U	USA	1.1	6
107	National U Singapore	Singapore	1.1	3
108	U California - Santa Barbara	USA	1.1	4
109	Southern Illinois U - Carbondale	USA	1.1	6
110	U California - Santa Cruz	USA	1.1	5
111	U Leicester	UK	1.0	3
112	U Tuebingen	Germany	1.0	1
113	North Carolina State U	USA	1.0	7
114	Virginia Commonwealth U	USA	1.0	4
115	U Hong Kong	China	1.0	5
116	U Zurich	Switzerland	1.0	5
117	Washington State U	USA	1.0	3
118	Humboldt U Berlin	Germany	1.0	5
119	Peking U	China	1.0	2
120	U North Carolina - Charlotte	USA	1.0	2
121	U Lille III (Charles de Gaulle)	France	1.0	1

呵呵，谢谢midi了。

可是这个finanical econ的排名把该学校的商学院金融系的排名算进去了吧？

比如第八名的斯坦福，我看他经济系没有多少是这个方向的导师阿。

倒是商学院金融系是数理金融的重镇。

以下是引用mao8888888在2004-12-1 4:50:43的发言：

呵呵，谢谢midi了。

可是这个finanical econ的排名把该学校的商学院金融系的排名算进去了吧？

比如第八名的斯坦福，我看他经济系没有多少是这个方向的导师阿。

倒是商学院金融系是数理金融的重镇。

是这样。 象HAVARD 这种经济系的金融师资可以和商学院平分秋色的大学还是比较少。比如CHICAGO的金融实力主要也是商学院支撑的，但其经济系确实有几位资产定价方面的大牛，经济系做finanical econ的PHD也很多。

香港是china的台湾就算taiwan，唉！多会儿能出现个大陆的学校啊？

呵呵，谢谢midi了。

crock

等级：论坛游民 文章：73 经验：229 积分：712 注册：2000-7-18

	楼顶

中国的经济学发展水平、普及与代际竞争 中国的经济学发展、普及与代际竞争

（与所有志于学的同道们共勉）

如果有人要对中国目前的经济学发展与研究水平做一个评价，我喜欢这样一个大胆的评价，也许不是非常准确。从整体上说，中国人对科学精神和人文精神及其关系的理解还没有达到欧洲文艺复兴时期的水准，整整要落后500年（因为就连自然科学方面的科学精神都还没有建立，那么从自然科学中借鉴其研究方法的社会科学更是步履蹒跚）；对自由市场制度及其运作以及政府和市场的关系的理解还远没有达到亚当斯密时代的英国人水准，整整落后220多年；就经济学职业圈子来说，整体的经济学知识水平还达不到马歇尔时代的水平，也就是达不到马歇尔时代职业学者的经济学训练和研究水平，落后整整一百年；即使是国内较好的研究圈子，其训练大约也止于萨谬尔森时代的经济学，落后整整50年；即使在国内经济学研究最为前沿的团队，熟悉的理论和经济学的分析技术大约是70－80年代，大约落后25年；如果你已经在国内接受最好的教育，自己也已经开始跟踪国际经济学的研究潮流，即使如此，大约也要落后国际研究10年，因为你今天看到的文章大部分是3年前写就的，因为在一流刊物上发文章平均要等待3年甚至更长，而这些文章的思想可能成型更早，而且当你读懂人家的文章的时候，他们已经开始新的探索了，前后的时间差大约是10年。

让我简单地补充一些说明，为什么我们在科学精神上还落后500年。直到今天，许多中国人甚至学者还不能完全理解科学和哲学的分野，也不能正确把握科学和人文的关系，我们有的是科学主义却没有“科学精神”。所谓科学主义，偏颇于把科学作为功利的手段，重在控制和利用；而科学精神却偏重于对真理的追求，重在探索与发现。从一开始，科学精神就和人文精神密不可分的，达芬奇既是科学家又是艺术家，没有心智自由就不可能有真正的科学发现（而我们的学者还缺乏心智自由，既有体制上的原因，也有个人的原因）。我一直有一种看法，也许是偏见，我认为没有做过科学探索的人，是不能体会科学精神的。这一点和艺术不一样，一个樵夫可以欣赏职业音乐家的演奏，但是没有研究训练的人，却很难进行真正的科学研究。所以我们说，在审美这个维度上，即使是最原始的部落，也有它的独特性和令人着迷之处（最近的人类学研究发现，美洲还存在一种没有“数”的概念的部落，几个以上就是“很多”）；但是显然不是所有的文明都发展出科学。有人可能对这样的一个说法不以为然，认为太过于“西方中心主义”，太过于以西方文明作为衡量发展的坐标。实际上，过于西方中心主义是有害的，但是，绝对的文化相对主义可能危害更大。文明如果没有优劣，那么何来“进步”？就某一项特定的思维方式而言我们是可以找到比较的尺度的。

作为经济科学普及落后的一个小例子（远不能说明落后）。我们经常会遇到这样让人啼笑皆非的事情。某某写了一篇文章，自以为是旷世的发现，说要申请“诺贝尔经济学奖”。从这种举措本身就可以知道，作者的信息是何等的闭塞，诺贝尔奖可不是国内的所谓的“＊＊＊奖”是要申请的。我本人也见到过类似的文章，看了文章之后，丝毫没有感觉可笑，而是感觉异常的悲哀：作者无异非常执著而有激情，这刚好可以跟文章中表现出来的幼稚与无知形成最强烈的对比。而且比这种幼稚更为可怕的是，作者完全陷进对自己的“理论”的偏执的地步，根本已经不能接受任何对他理论的挑战。这当然是一个悲剧，而且不仅是个人的悲剧：那些占有优越的办公条件，拿着数额客观的科学基金，有着耀人的头衔的学者不潜心学问；而偏偏那些信息闭塞、缺乏交流、在现实生活中颠簸流离的低层江湖学者却要试图从中寻求精神寄托；可是偏偏江湖学者的寄托却是建立在虚幻和无知的基础之上？到了这种地步，无论是有没有人指出他的无知，也无论他自己相不相信自己的无知，都已经是一个悲剧。但是，所有人都知道，将这个悲剧变成喜剧的方法不是颁给他诺贝尔奖，尽管没有什么比这个更大的喜剧了。

科学发展到现阶段，已经没有民间科学了，经济学也一样。没有严格的训练，就根本谈不上做研究，不要拿亚里斯多德和孔子时代来说事。道理很简单，只要是科学，它的知识必定在时间上是可积累的，否则就不是真正的科学。例如牛顿毕生探索的成果，今天一个高中生也能算出，所以过去的巨人的知识注定要被后人超过，因为后人站在了他的肩膀之上（相比之下，中国为什么没有科学，因为前人没有提供坚实的可供站立的肩膀，而后人却又喜欢另起炉灶，结果几千年来，盖的还是茅草房）。所以，我们的几乎所有的科学方法和体系是从西方引进的，经济学当然也不例外。但是，需要注意的是，一个主要靠知识的“引进”而不是靠本国的原创而达到科学进步的社会又会面临一个特殊的困境，这就是我要说的代际竞争。

一个人在年轻的时候，他的学习曲线比较陡峭（学的快，例如在大学拿到博士之前的30年），到了年老的时候，学习新知识的能力就会下降。一个社会（或者一个时代）也是类似，在处于知识的急剧引进的时候，社会的学习曲线就比较陡峭（知识进步更快），例如这十年来的经济学；在封闭或者处于知识前沿的社会（时代）知识进步可能就比较缓慢（有时候也有很快的进步例如20世纪上半叶的物理学，前沿国家也进步很快，但是引进国家可能更快如果能顺利引进）。那么可以想像，如果在年轻的时候遇到社会学习曲线比较陡峭的时代，无疑是幸运的，你学的快，学到的东西也多，也能使学术生命比较长，这叫生逢其时；如果年轻的时候遇到社会学习曲线很平坦，那么学到的东西就少。不幸的是，年轻的时候社会知识进步很慢，但有可能等你年老学习能力下降的时候，偏偏遇上社会知识进步很快的时代，那么就不得不面临年轻一代的挑战，这也许可以叫生不逢时。80年代以后的中国的经济学发展大致符合这个图像。其中注定有一代人或几代人要承担这种代价。对于某一代人而言，他遭遇的悲剧是：当他在读研究生的时候，老师讲萨谬尔森的《经济学》还是前沿；但当他毕业的时候，本科生都开始学范里安的《中级教程》了（至少硕士如此）；当他到了要评职称的时候，《高级教程》已经不新鲜了；他要当博导，他的博士却要学MWG的《微观理论》（目前国际通用博士课程教材）。不夸张地说，有些学生还没有毕业，他在学校里所学的知识结构就已经过时。你想像过这样的困境吗？一个企业，当它的产品还没有上市的时候，市场上的流行的产品就已经比它先进了，还没有生产，就已遭淘汰。这是一种代际的不公平，有非常复杂的原因，许多人是其中的受害者，是无辜的。但是对这种时局的两种态度却使人高下立判。高尚的学者能在这个时候主动让贤，竭力地推动学术进步；相反，一些不智之士却十分恋栈，试图处处阻挠整个社会的知识进步，阻挠知识的引进，恨不得年轻人学到的东西比他还少。

在目前这样的研究环境里，一个20岁的年轻人觉得他身边的同道甚至觉得导师不过如此，不值得惊讶。如果你在国内的二流的研究团队里，你超过他们20年，离国际前沿还起码有30年的差距；如果你已经在国内的一流的研究团队里，你超过他们20年，里国际前沿还可能有10年的差距。所以，一个二十岁的年轻人看四十岁的前辈的东西（指那些严肃的研究，抄袭另当别论），首先应该自问，当我四十岁的时候，那时二十岁的人会怎么看我呢？对于年轻的学子来说，如果要走学术的道路，要极力避免的事就是“还没有出厂就遭淘汰”的悲剧在自己身上发生。最好早早有自己的职业生涯规划，天生我才必有用，越早找到自己的职业生涯的定位越好，对自己对社会都有好处。至于现在还在校园的莘莘学子们，尤其是本科生们，努力吧！不要担心现在学术环境，唯一重要的任务是学习最为前沿的理论，国内大部分文章都可以不要看，大部分的杂志都可以不要读，当然还要少上BBS。你们不是和现在的老朽们竞争，因为你们的市场在将来，只要你们不要沾他们的坏习气（抄袭、一稿多投、不求甚解、自吹自擂、坐井观天、沽名钓誉、不识时务），你们在竞争中的致胜之道已经确确实实掌握在你们手中了。

[此贴子已经被作者于2004-12-3 2:20:09编辑过]