¿Æ˹ÍíÄ꾯¸æ£ºÎ÷·½¾¼ÃѧÂÙΪ½ºþÆÊõ£¡
2013-09-0404:02:48
http://www.guancha.cn/jiajinjing/2013_09_04_169995.shtml
2013Äê9ÔÂ2ÈÕ£¬1991Äê¶Èŵ±´¶û¾¼Ãѧ½±µÃÖ÷ÂÞÄɵ¡¤¿Æ˹ÊÅÊÀ£¬ÏíÄê102Ëê¡£
¿Æ˹µÄ²úȨÀíÂÛºÍÖƶȾ¼Ãѧ£¬ÔÚÖйúµÄ¾¼ÃÌåÖƸĸï¹ý³Ì±»¹ãΪÒýÓ㬿Æ˹Òò´Ë³ÉÁËÔÚÖйúÓ°Ïì×î´óµÄÎ÷·½¾¼Ãѧ¼ÒÖ®Ò»¡£¶ÔÓÚÊÅÕߣ¬Æä¡°ÒÅÑÔ¡±×ÜÊÇÊÜÈ˹Ø×¢£¬¿Æ˹µÄ¡°ÒÅÑÔ¡±ÊÇʲôÄØ£¿
2006ÄêÏÄ£¬¿Æ˹95Ëêʱ£¬·¢±íÁËһƪ±»ÆÕ±éÈÏΪ¿°³ÆÆäѧÊõÒÅÖöµÄÎÄÕ¡¶¾¼ÃѧµÄÍƵ¼£º·ÑÏ£¶û³µÌ幫˾ÓëͨÓÃÆû³µ¹«Ë¾°¸Àý¡·(Coase, Ronald. ¡°The Conduct of Economics:The Example of Fisher Body and General Motors¡±, Journalof Economics & Management Strategy 15 (2), 2006: 255-278.)¡£¾¡¹ÜºóÀ´ÔÚ2011Äê¿Æ˹ÓÖÓëÆäÖúÊÖÍõÄþºÏ×÷·¢±íÁË¡¶¹¤ÒµµÄÉú²ú½á¹¹£º´´Òµ¾¼ÃµÄ´´ÐÂÑо¿Òé³Ì¡·£¨Coase,Ronald., and Ning Wang., ¡°The Industrial Structure ofProduction: A Research Agenda for Innovation in an Entrepreneurial Economy¡±, Entrepreneurship Research Journal 2 (1), 2011.£©£¬µ«ÕâƪÎÄÕ²»¾ßÓС°Ñ§ÊõÒÅÖö¡±ÐÔÖÊ¡£
ÔÚ¡¶¾¼ÃѧµÄÍƵ¼¡·Õâƪ¡°Ñ§ÊõÒÅÖö¡±ÖУ¬¿Æ˹˵ÁËЩʲôÄØ£¿2006ÄêÏÄ£¬ÎÒÔÚä¯ÀÀÍøҳʱ£¬ÕýºÃ·µ½JEMS£¨¡¶¾¼ÃÓë¹ÜÀíÕ½ÂÔѧ¿¯¡·£©2006ÄêÏļ¾ºÅµÄÖ÷Ò³£¬³Ô¾ª¿´µ½ÕâÆÚµÄÊ×ƪÎÄÕ¾¹È»ÊÇ¿Æ˹дµÄ£¡ÓÚÊÇÆȲ»¼°´ýµØÏÂÔØÁË´ËÎÄ£¬ÓÖ·¢¸øÁ˼¸Î»ÅóÓÑ£¬ÆäÖÐһλ¾¼ÃѧÕß»ØÐÅ˵£ºÕæÊDz»¿É˼Ò顪¡ªÕâ²»ÊÇÕÅÎå³£Ìáµ½¿Æ˹дÁ˼¸Ê®Äêûд³öÀ´µÄÂÛÎÄÂð£¿
ÕâƪÎÄÕºܳ¤£¬ÓÐ24Ò³£¬ÐèÒª×øÏÂÀ´¶Á°ëÌì¡£µÚÒ»±é¿´µÄʱºò£¬¾õµÃÓеãÔÆÉ»ÎíÕÖ£ºÕâÎÄÕÂÊÇÒª½²¸ö¹ÊÊÂÂð£¬ÊǾ¼ÃѧÂ𣿹ýÁ˼¸Ì죬¾¹ý¶Ô¸ÃÎÄÇ°Òòºó¹ûµÄÊáÀí£¬²ÅŪÃ÷°×¿Æ˹Ҫ±í´ïµÄÊÇʲô¡£
¿Æ˹д×÷¸ÃÎĵÄÔµÓÉ£¬ÐèÒª´Ó¾¼ÃѧÖÐһƪ¡°¾µäÂÛÎÄ¡±¡¶×ÝÏòÒ»Ì廯£¬¿É¼·Õ¼ÐÔ×â½ðÓ뾺ÕùÐÔµÞÔ¼¹ý³Ì¡·(Benjamin Klein, R.G.Crawford, and A.A.Alchian., ¡°Vertical Integration, Appropriable Rents, and the CompetitiveContracting Process¡±. Journal of Law and Economics.1978, 21:297¨C326.)˵Æð¡£
1978Ä꣬¾¼Ãѧ¼Ò±¾½ÜÃ÷¡¤¿ËÀ³Òò£¨Benjamin Klein£©Óë°¢ÃÅ¡¤°¢¶ûÇÕ£¨Armen A.Alchian£©ºÏд¡¶×ÝÏòÒ»Ì廯£¬¿É¼·Õ¼ÐÔ×â½ðÓ뾺ÕùÐÔµÞÔ¼¹ý³Ì¡·Ö®ºó£¬¡°×ÝÏòÒ»Ì廯¡±¾Í³ÉÁ˲úÒµ×éÖ¯ÀíÂÛÖÐ×îÖØÒªµÄ»°ÌâÖ®Ò»¡£¶øÿ̸¡°×ÝÏòÒ»Ì廯¡±£¬Ôò±ØÌᡰͨÓÃÆû³µ¹«Ë¾²¢¹º·ÑÏ£¶û³µÌ幫˾¡±°¸Àý£¬´ÓÖÐÌá³öÁ˺ܶ൱´úÎ÷·½¾¼Ãѧ×÷Ϊ»ù±¾¸ÅÄîµÄ¶«Î÷£¬Èç¡°²»Í걸ÆõÔ¼¡±¡¢¡°×ʲúרÓÃÐÔ¡±µÈ£¬ÄÃÕâЩÑо¿µ±¹ý·¹ÍëµÄÎ÷·½¾¼Ãѧ½ç¡°´óÍó¶ù¡±Öڶ࣬°üÀ¨°ÂÀû¸¥¡¤ÍþÁ®Ä·É£¨Olive Williamson£¬2009Äêŵ±´¶û¾¼Ãѧ½±»ñµÃÕߣ©¡¢°ÂÀû¸¥¡¤¹þÌØ£¨Oliver Hart£©¡¢±£ÂÞ¡¤ÇÇ˹¿Æ£¨Paul Joskow£©µÈ¡£±¾½ÜÃ÷¡¤¿ËÀ³ÒòÔò³ÉÁË¡°×ÝÏòÒ»Ì廯¡±Ñо¿µÄȨÍþ¡£
±¾½ÜÃ÷¡¤¿ËÀ³ÒòÔÚ¡¶×ÝÏòÒ»Ì廯£¬¿É¼·Õ¼ÐÔ×â½ðÓ뾺ÕùÐÔµÞÔ¼¹ý³Ì¡·Öн²µÄ¹ÊÊÂÊÇÕâÑùµÄ£º
1917Ä꣬ͨÓÃÆû³µ¹«Ë¾ÓëרÃÅÉú²úÆû³µ³µÉíµÄ¹«Ë¾·ÑÏ£¶û³µÌ幫˾ǩ¶©ÁËÒ»·ÝºÏͬ£¬¹æ¶¨·ÑÏ£¶ûΪͨÓÃÆû³µÉú²ú½ðÊô³µÉí¡£´ËǰͨÓõijµÉí¶¼ÊÇľͷ×öµÄ¡£ÎªÁËÖ´ÐÐÕâ±Ê´óºÏͬ£¬·ÑÏ£¶û´óÁ¿Í¶×Ê£¬½øÐм¼Êõ¸ÄÔ죬¶øÐÂÉÏÂíµÄ¼¼ÊõÖ»ÄÜרÃÅÖÆÔì³µÉíÓã¬Ëµ°×Á˾ÍÊÇÖ»ÄÜÂô¸øͨÓÃÁË£¬ÊÇν¡°×ʲúרÓÃÐÔ¡±¡£ÓÚÊÇ£¬ÎÊÌâ²úÉúÁË£¬¼ÙÈçÕâʱͨÓÃÒÔ¼õÉÙ¶©»õÏàÍþв£¬ÒªÇó·ÑÏ£¶û½µ¼Û£¬·ÑÏ£¶û½«²»µÃ²»´Ó£¬·ñÔòͶ×ʸ㼼Êõ¸ÄÔìµÄÇ®°×»¨ÁË¡£Õâ¾Í½Ðhold up£¨Ð®³Ö¡¢ÇÃÖñ¸Ü£©¡£ÓÚÊÇ1919ÄêË«·½²¹³äÁËÒ»¸öÐÒ飬¹æ¶¨Í¨ÓÃÔÚ½ñºó10ÄêÀïÖ»´Ó·ÑÏ£¶û¹ºÂòÈ«²¿ËùÐè³µÉí¡£µ«¼¸Äêºó£¬½ðÊô³µÉíµÄÊг¡ÐèÇó¼±¾çÉÏÉý£¬Í¨ÓÃΪÁ˽µµÍ³É±¾£¬ÔÚ1925ÄêÒªÇó·ÑÏ£¶û°Ñ³§Ö·°áǨµ½Í¨Óø½½ü£¬µ«·ÑÏ£¶û¾Ü¾øÕâÑù×ö£¬¶øÇÒ»¹Ê¹ÓÃÀͶ¯Ãܼ¯Ðͼ¼ÊõºÍ³¤¾àÀëÔËÊä»ñµÃÁË×ܼÛ17.6%µÄÀûÈ󣬵ÈÓÚ·´¹ýÀ´hold upÁËͨÓÃһϡ£×îÖÕÖÂʹͨÓöԷÑÏ£¶û½øÐÐÈ«ÅÌÊÕ¹º¡£
±¾½ÜÃ÷¡¤¿ËÀ³Òò½²ÁËÕâ¸ö¹ÊÊÂÖ®ºó£¬ÈçºÎ½â¾öholdupÎÊÌâ³ÉÁ˲úÒµ×éÖ¯Ñо¿Èȵ㣬ºóÐøÑо¿¶¼ÊÇÔÚËû½²µÄ¹ÊÊ»ù´¡ÉϽøÐеġ£±¾½ÜÃ÷¡¤¿ËÀ³ÒòÌá³öµÄ½â¾ö·½°¸¾ÍÊÇ¡°×ÝÏòÒ»Ì廯¡±£¬½«²úÒµÉÏÏÂÓκϲ¢µ½Ò»¸öÆóÒµÀ¾Í²»ÅÂhold upÁË¡£
¿Æ˹µÄ¡¶¾¼ÃѧµÄÍƵ¼¡·Êµ¼ÊÉÏÊǶÔhold upÎÊÌâ½ü30Äê·¢Õ¹µÄÒ»¸öÊáÀí£¬ÉõÖÁÊǶԱ¾½ÜÃ÷¡¤¿ËÀ³ÒòµÄÒ»¸öÇåËã¡£¿Æ˹ÕâÈ˲»ÐÅа£¬±ðÈ˵±³É¶¨Â۵Ķ«Î÷ËûÆ«Òª×Ô¼ºÕÒÀ´µÚÒ»ÊÖ²ÄÁÏ¿´¿´¡£¿Æ˹Ñо¿ÁË´óÁ¿Í¨ÓúͷÑÏ£¶ûµÄÔʼ²ÄÁÏ£¬°üÀ¨µ±Ê±µÄºÏÔ¼¡¢Ë«·½µÄͨÐÅÒÔ¼°ÆäËûÏà¹ØÎļþ£¬·¢ÏÖKleinµÄ¹Êʾ¹È»ÊÇϹ±àµÄ£¡
¿Æ˹·¢ÏÖËùÓеÄÖ¤¾Ý¶¼Ö¸ÏòÒ»¸ö½áÂÛ£º·ÑÏ£¶û´Óδholdup¹ýͨÓã¡¿Æ˹ͨ¹ý¿¼¾Ý·¢ÏÖ£¬1925ÄêͨÓÃÒªÇó·ÑÏ£¶û°áǨ³§Ö·µÄÊÂÇé²¢²»´æÔÚ£¡ÒòΪ·ÑÏ£¶ûÒѾÔÚͨÓø½½üÓÐÁ˳§·¿£¬¶øËùν·ÑÏ£¶ûͨ¹ý½µµÍ¡°¼¼Êõº¬Á¿¡±ºÍ³¤Í¾°áÔ˵ķ½·¨»ñÈ¡ÀûÈó£¬Ò²ÊDz»¿ÉÄܵģ¬ÒòΪ·ÑÏ£¶û³ýÁËͨÓ㬻¹ÓÐÐí¶à´ó¿Í»§£¬×öÕâô±¿µÄÊÂÇ飬²»ÊÇ×ÔËð¾ºÕùÁ¦Â𣿿Æ˹ָ³ö£¬µ±Ê±µÄÕæʵÇé¿öÊÇͨÓý¨Á¢ÁËרÃŵijµÉíÉú²ú¹¤³§È»ºó×â¸øÁË·ÑÏ£¶û£¬ËÒ²²»±Øhold upË¡£ÓÉ´Ë£¬¿Æ˹ÈÏΪ£¬ÆõÔ¼²»Í걸ÐÔºÍ×ʲúרÓÃÐÔÎÊÌâÍêÈ«¿ÉÒÔͨ¹ý¶©Á¢³¤ÆÚºÏͬÓÈжø½â£¬¸ù±¾²»ÐèÒª¡°×ÝÏòÒ»Ì廯¡±£¬hold upÍêÈ«ÊÇƾ¿ÕÒÜÏëµÄ£¡
¡¶¾¼ÃѧµÄÍƵ¼¡·µÄ×îºóÒ»¶Î£¬¿Æ˹Ìá³öµÄÎÊÌâÒѾ¸ù±¾²»ÊÇÆóÒµÀíÂÛÎÊÌ⣬¶øÊÇ£ºÎªÊ²Ã´Õâô¶à¾¼Ãѧ¼Ò»á°ÑÒ»¸öϹ±àµÄ¹ÊÊ·îΪ¾µäÄØ£¿¿Æ˹ÓÃÁËÒ»¶ÎÒýÎÄ˵£¬The conclusion is obvious: a few scientists are likely no better andno worse than the few members of the general population who are crooks andcharlatans.£¨½áÂÛÏÔ¶øÒ×¼û£ºÄ³Ð©¿Æѧ¼ÒÂÙÂäµ½¸úÆ×Ӻͽºþ¡°Æø¹¦´óʦ¡±Ò»¸öµµ´ÎÁË£©¡£
µ«ÊÇ¿Æ˹ÈÏΪ£¬»¹²»Ö¹Èç´Ë£¬Æ×Ӻ͡°Æø¹¦´óʦ¡±ÆðÂëÐÄÀïÃ÷°××Ô¼ºËµµÄÊǼٻ°£¬¶øÕâÀïµÄ¾¼Ãѧ¼ÒÃÇÔòÐÅÒÔΪÕæ¡£¿Æ˹ÈÏΪ×îÖÕµÄÔÒòÔÚÓÚ¡ª¡ªËûÒѾÔÚŵ±´¶û»ñ½±Ö´ÊÖÐ˵¹ý¡ª¡ª¾¼Ãѧ¼ÒÔÚÑо¿ËûÃÇÏëÏóµÄ¶«Î÷¶ø²»ÊÇÕæʵµÄÊÀ½ç£¡
¶Áµ½ÕâÀïÎÒ·½¸Ðµ½£ºÀÏÒ¯×ÓÕæÊDz»¼òµ¥£¬Õâ¿É±ÈÌá³öÒ»¸öеĽâÊÍÇ¿¶àÁË£¡ÉÏÉýµ½ÕÜѧ£¬²Å¿Éν˼Ïë¼Ò£¡¾¼ÃѧÊÇÒ»ÖÖÂß¼½¨¹¹£¬¶øÔÚ×öÈκÎÂß¼½¨¹¹µÄʱºò£¬¶¼Ðèʱʱ½÷¼ÇÁ½¼þÊ£ºÒ»Ô»ÀúÊ·ÊÇÏÈÓÚÂß¼µÄ£»¶þÔ»ÎÒÃÇËùÒÀ¾ÝµÄÖÊÁÏ£¬ÊÇÇ°È˽¨¹¹¶ø³ÉµÄ¡£