邹恒甫补充一点蔡洪滨的学术水平

Lenovo0423 发表于 2012-3-22 11:25
张维迎，离开北大了。蔡洪滨，能稳住？很多人无需我们争斗，他是天然的斗争对象

北大光华的院长必须听厉以宁的话。

arlionn 发表于 2012-3-22 08:30
邹老师和蔡老师的论文引用率其实可比性有点问题，邹先生的文章是1998前后发表的，而蔡的则是2004,2005发的。 ...

邹老师发表于2006年的论文的引用率都比蔡的高呢

after-drunk 发表于 2012-3-22 17:19
邹老师发表于2006年的论文的引用率都比蔡的高呢

其实，有时候也不能仅仅拿引用率来说事，毕竟每个领域的习惯不同。应用领域的引用率通常比纯理论领域的引用率高。有些领域甚至存在曲高和寡的现象。

arlionn 发表于 2012-3-22 17:48
其实，有时候也不能仅仅拿引用率来说事，毕竟每个领域的习惯不同。应用领域的引用率通常比纯理论领域的引 ...

请看邹老师的信：这也可以说明为什么蔡洪滨出钱请方汉明，陈玉宇，周黎安，albert park， vernon henderson等人帮他写应用论文。
但是，蔡洪滨要赶上邹恒甫老师的引用率是不可能的。邹老师在无名气的期刊《review of development economics》里发的一文就有355个引用，比蔡洪滨在JPubE和AER两篇最多引用加起来还多。有时，高引用率并不一定要在好期刊，邹老师的论文说明了此点，了不起！

arlionn 发表于 2012-3-22 17:48
其实，有时候也不能仅仅拿引用率来说事，毕竟每个领域的习惯不同。应用领域的引用率通常比纯理论领域的引 ...

请看邹老师在水货期刊发的一篇论文的355个引用：
Income inequality is not harmful for growth: theory and evidence…, H Zou - Review of Development Economics, 1998 - Wiley Online Library
The paper shows that income inequality may theoretically lead to higher economic growth if
public consumption enters the utility function. Empirically, baseline estimations and a
sensitivity analysis show that income inequality is positively, and most of the time ...
Cited by 355 - Related articles - All 15 versions

但是，蔡洪滨要赶上邹恒甫老师的引用率是不可能的。邹老师在无名气的期刊《review of development economics》里发的一文就有355个引用，比蔡洪滨在JPubE和AER两篇最多引用加起来还多。有时，高引用率并不一定要在好期刊，邹老师的论文说明了此点，了不起！
State corroding federalism[PDF] from kuleuven.ac.be
H Cai… - Journal of Public Economics, 2004 - Elsevier
Competition among local governments in a decentralized political system is often thought to
discipline lazy or corrupt officials, improving public good provision and increasing welfare.
Some scholars note possible distortions due to spillovers or a 'race-to-the-bottom', but ...
Cited by 170 - Related articles - All 18 versions
Does competition for capital discipline governments? Decentralization, globalization, and public policy[PDF] from ucla.edu
H Cai… - The American economic review, 2005 - JSTOR
Does competition to attract mobile capital discipline governments? Two bodies of literature
contend that it does. The first sees such discipline as harmful. Scholars argue that the fear of
capital outflows restricts governments from providing welfare services, environmental ...
Cited by 149 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 25 versions

arlionn 发表于 2012-3-22 17:48
其实，有时候也不能仅仅拿引用率来说事，毕竟每个领域的习惯不同。应用领域的引用率通常比纯理论领域的引 ...

但是，蔡洪滨要赶上邹恒甫老师的引用率是不可能的。邹老师在无名气的期刊《review of development economics》里发的一文就有355个引用，比蔡洪滨在JPubE和AER两篇最多引用加起来还多。有时，高引用率并不一定要在好期刊，邹老师的论文说明了此点，了不起！邹老师在不是顶尖的《journal of urban economics》的四篇文章都有很高引用：
Fiscal decentralization and economic growth: A cross-country study…, H Zou - Journal of Urban economics, 1998 - Elsevier
We use a panel data set of 46 countries over the 1970–1989 period to investigate the
relationship between fiscal decentralization and economic growth. We find a negative
relationship between fiscal decentralization and growth in developing countries, but none ...
Cited by 497 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 10 versions

Fiscal decentralization and economic growth in the United StatesD Xie, H Zou… - Journal of Urban Economics, 1999 - Elsevier
In a simple model of endogenous growth with spending by different levels of government,
we demonstrate how fiscal decentralization affects the long-run growth rate of the economy.
Applying the model to the US economy, we find that the existing spending shares for state ...
Cited by 238 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 10 versions
How does fiscal decentralization affect aggregate, national, and subnational government size?[PDF] from tuwien.ac.at
…, H Zou - Journal of Urban Economics, 2002 - Elsevier
Beyond conducting the usual regression analysis of the relationship between fiscal
decentralization and aggregate government size (national and subnational combined), this
paper makes the first attempt to examine how different fiscal decentralization measures ...
Cited by 97 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 14 versions

arlionn 发表于 2012-3-22 17:48
其实，有时候也不能仅仅拿引用率来说事，毕竟每个领域的习惯不同。应用领域的引用率通常比纯理论领域的引 ...

邹老师的论文就是引用率较高：
The composition of public expenditure and economic growth[PDF] from worldbank.org
…, V Swaroop, H Zou - Journal of monetary economics, 1996 - Elsevier
Noting that the literature has focused on the link between the level of public expenditure and
growth, we derive conditions under which a change in the composition of expenditure leads
to a higher steady-state growth rate of the economy. The conditions depend not just on the ...
Cited by 807 - Related articles - All 15 versions
Explaining international and intertemporal variations in income inequality[PDF] from cenet.org.cn
…, L Squire, H Zou - The Economic Journal, 1998 - Wiley Online Library
This paper explores the propositions that, income inequality is relatively stable within
countries; and that it varies significantly among countries. A new and expanded data set
provides broad support for both propositions. Drawing on a political economy and capital ...
Cited by 724 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 20 versions

Fiscal decentralization and economic growth: A cross-country study…, H Zou - Journal of Urban economics, 1998 - Elsevier
We use a panel data set of 46 countries over the 1970–1989 period to investigate the
relationship between fiscal decentralization and economic growth. We find a negative
relationship between fiscal decentralization and growth in developing countries, but none ...
Cited by 497 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 10 versions

Fiscal decentralization, public spending, and economic growth in China[PDF] from nccu.edu.tw
…, H Zou - Journal of Public Economics, 1998 - Elsevier
This study of China demonstrates how the allocation of fiscal resources between the central
and local governments has affected economic growth since reforms began in the late 1970s.
We find that a higher degree of fiscal decentralization of government spending is ...
Cited by 517 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 21 versions

Income inequality is not harmful for growth: theory and evidence…, H Zou - Review of Development Economics, 1998 - Wiley Online Library

Cited by 355 - Related articles - All 15 versions

Fiscal decentralization and economic growth in the United StatesD Xie, H Zou… - Journal of Urban Economics, 1999 - Elsevier

Cited by 238 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 10 versions

Corruption, income distribution, and growth[PDF] from psu.edu
…, LC Xu, H Zou - Economics & Politics, 2000 - Wiley Online Library

Cited by 189 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 16 versions

[] The spirit of capitalism'and long-run growth[PDF] from worldbank.org
H Zou - European Journal of Political Economy, 1994 - Elsevier
Abstract In this paper, we will show that the capitalist-spirit approach to economic growth has
been developed by Adam Smith, Karl Marx, Max Weber and John Maynard Keynes and
many others. It can be demonstrated that countries with different degree of the capitalist ...
Cited by 153 - Related articles - All 15 versions

[PDF] Intergovernmental fiscal relations in Indonesia[PDF] from mekonginfo.org
…, A Bagchi, B Binder, H Zou - World Bank Discussion …, 1994 - mekonginfo.org

Cited by 109 - Related articles - BL Direct - All 9 versions

[BOOK] Finance and income inequality: test of alternative theories[HTML] from google.com
GRG Clarke, H Zou… - 2003 - books.google.com

Cited by 124 - Related articles - All 24 versions

arlionn 发表于 2012-3-22 17:48
其实，有时候也不能仅仅拿引用率来说事，毕竟每个领域的习惯不同。应用领域的引用率通常比纯理论领域的引 ...

怎么样？你无语了？

这个数据有水分啊，一个第一作者，一个第二作者