看对于郎咸平的批判想到的

    那个冠以“批判”郎咸平的帖子，就是哗众取宠! 真够无聊的! 真正论文没看几篇，经济学、管理学还没有入门就开始批判了。有几位引用张五常评价郎的话直接当成论据来批判郎。

    真搞不懂，张五常这样的人还有这么多人追随，让他先把在美国逃的税交齐了吧!

以下是引用zhanglisysu在2008-8-8 14:50:00的发言：

    那个冠以“批判”郎咸平的帖子，就是哗众取宠! 真够无聊的! 真正论文没看几篇，经济学、管理学还没有入门就开始批判了。有几位引用张五常评价郎的话直接当成论据来批判郎。

    真搞不懂，张五常这样的人还有这么多人追随，让他先把在美国逃的税交齐了吧!

在经济学术界的地位上，朗函平的地位可是远远比不上张五常呢。 就是在香港大学里面，张五常的职位也是比郎函平要高的。

以下是引用xinxin2006在2008-8-8 15:01:00的发言：

在经济学术界的地位上，朗函平的地位可是远远比不上张五常呢。 就是在香港大学里面，张五常的职位也是比郎函平要高的。

单从财务的方面，郎咸平的地位华人当中能和他相比的也不多。

不过如果谈论起经济学，郎咸平与张五常相比，确实相差的多了。

你看看两个人发的文章，再来评价谁比谁差很多，我感觉你的这种评价象是关公战秦琼。但是郎发的文章的档次和数量是张不可及的。郎AER 2篇，JPE3篇，JF6篇，JFE11篇。 试问一下，张先生发了AER吗？ 张五常 Cheung, Steven N S (1969) "Transaction Costs, Risk Aversion, and the Choice of Contractual Arrangements," Journal of Law and Economics, Vol. 12, Issue 1, pp. 23-42. Cheung, Steven N S (1970) "The Structure of a Contract and the Theory of a Non-Exclusive Resource," Journal of Law and Economics, Vol. 13, Issue 1, pp. 49-70. Cheung, Steven N S (1970) "Enforcement of Property Rights in Children, and the Marriage Contract," Economic Journal, Vol. 82, Issue 326, pp. 641-57. Cheung, Steven N S (1973) "The Fable of the Bees: An Economic Investigation," Journal of Law and Economics, Vol. 16, Issue 1, pp. 11-33. Cheung, Steven N S (1974) "A Theory of Price Control," Journal of Law and Economics, Vol. 17, Issue 1, pp. 53-71. Cheung, Steven N S (1975) "Roofs or Stars: The Stated Intents and Actual Effects of a Rents Ordinance," Economic Inquiry, Volume 13, Issue 1, pp. 1-21. Cheung, Steven N S (1982) "Property Rights in Trade Secrets," Economic Inquiry, Volume 20, Issue 1, pp. 40-53. Cheung, Steven N S (1977) "Why are better seats 'underpriced'," Economic Inquiry, Volume 15, Issue 4, pp. 513-522. Cheung, Steven N S (1983) "The Contractual Nature of The Firm," Journal of Law and Economics, Vol. 26, Issue 1, pp. 1-26. Cheung, Steven N S (1995) "Economic Interactions: China vis-a-vis Hong Kong," Contemporary Economic Policy, Vol. 13, Issue 1, pp. 1-9. Cheung, Steven N S (1996) "A Simplistic General Equilibrium Theory of Corruption," Contemporary Economic Policy, Vol. 14, Issue 3, pp. 1-5. Cheung, Steven N S (1998) "Deng Xiaoping's Great Transformation," Contemporary Economic Policy, Vol. 16, Issue 2, pp. 125-35. Cheung, Steven N S (1998) "The Curse of Democracy as an Instrument of Reform in Collapsed Communist Economies," Contemporary Economic Policy, Volume 16, Issue 2, pp. 247-49. 郎咸平 Young, Leslie S.F., Gadhoum, Yoser, Lang, Larry H. P., Who Controls US . European Financial Management

Claessens, S., Fan, P.H. Joseph, Lang, Larry H. P., The benefits and costs of group affiliation: Evidence from East Asia . Emerging Markets Review, Volume 7, Issue 1, 1-26

2006

Fong, Wai-ming, Attig, Najah, Gadhoum, Yoser, Lang, Larry H. P., Effects of Large Shareholding on Information Asymmetry and Stock Liquidity . Journal of Banking and Finance, 30, 2875-2892

2006

Claessens, S., Djankov, S., Fan, P.H. Joseph, Lang, Larry H. P., When does corporate diversification matter to productivity and performance? Evidence from East Asia . Pacific-Basin Finance Journal, vol.11, No. 3, 239-392

2003

Lang, Larry H. P., Claessens, S., Djankov, S., Fan, J., Disentangling the Incentive and Enchanching Effects of Large Shareholdings: Case in East Aisa . Journal of Finance, 57, 2741-2771

2003

Lang, Larry H. P., Doukas, J., International Diversification and Firm Performance . Journal of International Business Studies, Issue 34

2003

Claessens, S., Djankov, S., Fan, P.H. Joseph, Lang, Larry H. P., Disentangling the Incentive and Entrenchment Effects of Large Shareholdings . Journal of Finance, 57, 2741-2771

2002

Lang, Larry H. P., Faccio, M., The Ultimate Ownership of Western European Corporations . Journal of Financial Economics, issue 65

2002

Lang, Larry H. P., Faccio, M., Young, L., Expropriation and Dividends . American Economic Review, 91, 1-25

2001

Young, Leslie S.F., Faccio, Mara, Lang, Larry H. P., Dividends and Expropriation . American Economic Review

2001

Fan, P.H. Joseph, Lang, Larry H. P., The Measurement of Relatedness: An Application to Corporate Diversification . Journal of Business, Vol. 73, No. 4, 629-660

2000

Lang, Larry H. P., Fan, J., The Measurement of Relatedness: An Application to Corporate Diversification . Journal of Business, 73, 629-660

2000

Lang, Larry H. P., Claessens, S., Djankov, S., Separation of Ownership from Control of East Asian Firms . Journal of Financial Economics, 58, 81-112

2000

Lang, Larry H. P., Doukas, J., Hall, P., The Pricing of Currency Risk in Japan . Journal Banking and Finance, 23, 1-20

1999

Lang, Larry H. P., Litzenberger, Robert H., Liu, A., Determinants of Interest Rate Swap Spreads . Journal Banking and Finance, 22, 1507-1532

1998

Lang, Larry H. P., Arshanapalli, B., Doukas, J., Common volatility in the Industrial Structure of Global Capital Markets . Journal of International Money and Finance, 16, 189-209

1997

Lang, Larry H. P., Ofek, E., Stulz, R., Leverage, Investment and Firm Growth . Journal of Financial Economics, 40, 3-29

1996

Lang, Larry H. P., Chan, K. C., Foresi, S., Does Money Explain Asset Returns? Theory and Evidence . Journal of Finance, 51, 345-361

1996

Lang, Larry H. P., Poulsen, A., Stulz, R., Asset Sales, Firm Performance and the Agency Costs of Managerial Discretion . Journal of Financial Economics, 37, 3-38

1995

Lang, Larry H. P., Stulz, R., Tobin's q, Corporate Diversification and Firm Performance . Journal of Political Economy, 102, 1248-1280

1994

Lang, Larry H. P., Litzenberger, R., Madrigal, V., Testing Financial Market Equilibrium under Asymmetric Information . Journal of Political Economy, 100, 317-348

1992

Lang, Larry H. P., Stulz, R., Contagion and Competition Intra-Industry Effects of Bankruptcy Announcements: An Empirical Analysis . Journal of Financial Economics, 32, 45-60

1992

Lang, Larry H. P., John, K., Netter, J., Voluntary Restructuring of Large Firms in Response to Performance Decline . Journal of Finance, 47, 891-917

1992

Lang, Larry H. P., Butler, K., The Forecast Accuracy of Individual Analysts: Evidence of Systematic Optimism and Pessimism . Journal of Accounting Research, 29, 150-156

1991

Lang, Larry H. P., John, K., Insider Trading Around Dividend Announcements: Theory and Evidence . Journal of Finance, 46, 1361-1390

1991

Lang, Larry H. P., Stulz, R., Walkling, R., A Test of the Free Cash Flow Hypothesis: The Case of Bidder Returns . Journal of Financial Economics, 29, 315-335

1991

Lang, Larry H. P., Gilson, S., John, K., Troubled Debt Restructuring: An Empirical Study of Private Reorganization of Firms in Default . Journal of Financial Economics, 27, 315-353

1990

Lang, Larry H. P., Litzenberger, Robert H., Dividend Announcements: Cash Flow Signalling vs. Free Cash Flow Hypotheses . Journal of Financial Economics, 24, 181-191

1989

Lang, Larry H. P., Stulz, R., Walkling, R., Managerial Performance, Tobin's Q and Successful Tender Offers . Journal of Financial Economics, 24, 137-154

1989

Lang, Larry H. P., Friend, I., An Empirical Test of the Impact of Managerial Self Interest on Corporate Capital Structure . Journal of Finance, 43, 271-281

1988

Lang, Larry H. P., Friend, I., The Size Effect of Stock Returns: Is It Simply A Risk Factor Not Adequately Reflected by the Usual Risk Measures? . Journal of Banking and Finance, 12, 13-30

楼上，把经济和财务之间的区别搞清楚好吗？

按照你这样比较论文，我大学里面我爸爸的助手发的论文都比朗还多呢。

郎发的就是美国经济评论、政治经济学期刊和金融经济学，那个不是经济学类的期刊啊？郎是从微观角度研究经济就不是经济了吗？

张五常有AER的文章吗？

以下是引用天下一人在2008-8-8 12:46:00的发言：

能够发现问题就很好了，要是能提出你说的解决方案，

那还用得着提出问题让人讨论吗，直接告诉大家怎么做就好了。

就像马克思提出问题：工人怎样才能不受剥削？

列宁给出答案：武装起义，从资本主义链条上最弱一环上取得突破，社会主义在一国的首先胜利。

毛主席给出答案：工农武装割据——农村包围城市，武装夺取政权。

当然这些不是最终的答案，还有很长的路要走。

[em01]

同样的道理，毛主席没能解决公有企业经营效率的问题，制度经济学系统的回答了这个问题并提出了解决方法

以下是引用xinxin2006在2008-8-8 15:36:00的发言：

楼上，把经济和财务之间的区别搞清楚好吗？

按照你这样比较论文，我大学里面我爸爸的助手发的论文都比朗还多呢。

以下是引用bajjio在2008-8-8 15:23:00的发言：

单从财务的方面，郎咸平的地位华人当中能和他相比的也不多。

不过如果谈论起经济学，郎咸平与张五常相比，确实相差的多了。

我想这样比较思路是不对的：

1、就算不是AER，五常大师当年的那篇论文也顶得上别人的百十篇，数量和质量没法比；

2、而现在的五常大师文章水平，开个玩笑，恐怕就算是和xinxin2006的父亲的助手比，也未必胜得过了。

3、郎咸平和张五常的学术地位，是不能决定现在他们言论的正确与否的。

4、不过我一直认为，五常大师、厉以宁大师这些老一辈的人，其实都是揣着明白装糊涂罢了。

以下是引用天下一人在2008-8-8 16:29:00的发言：

我想这样比较思路是不对的：

1、就算不是AER，五常大师当年的那篇论文也顶得上别人的百十篇，数量和质量没法比；

2、而现在的五常大师文章水平，开个玩笑，恐怕就算是和xinxin2006的父亲的助手比，也未必胜得过了。

3、郎咸平和张五常的学术地位，是不能决定现在他们言论的正确与否的。

4、不过我一直认为，五常大师、厉以宁大师这些老一辈的人，其实都是揣着明白装糊涂罢了。

   目前各个学术领域的研究是高度专业化，以日本人清泷信宏为例，他的主要研究领域就是宏观经济学和货币经济学，他一般不会对微观领域的问题发表意见。一般而言，还是在自己研究领域的范围之内发表意见，不容易引起不必要的争论。在我印象当中，朗咸平似乎主要是研究财务和公司治理之类的，宏观经济学等领域似乎并不是他的专长。